L4M1 Scope and Influence of Procurement and Supply Questions and Answers

- Mention of some of the following benefits with at least one example provided against each; cost savings, time savings, more efficient, higher levels of transparency, easier to access historical records to inform upon decision making, mitigates risks such as fraudulent spending, easier to track spend against budgets, ensures compliance with regulations, provides ‘real-time’ information, paperless communications (so more environmentally friendly), assists in Supply Chain Management and integration with supply partners.

- I’d suggest 5 is a good amount to aim for

Example Essay

Procurement stands to gain numerous benefits from the adoption of electronic systems. These electronic tools and systems bring efficiency, accuracy, transparency, and cost-effectiveness to the procurement process. Here are several compelling reasons why procurement should leverage electronic systems:

Cost savings – the use of electronic tools saves organisations money. Although there is an initial cost outlay, over time the systems will save the organisation money. For example the use of e-procurement tools can save money by accessing a wider pool of suppliers. For example, when using an e-sourcing portal, a tender may reach a larger number of suppliers- this makes the tender more competitive thus driving down prices. Compared to traditional methods such as phoning suppliers for prices, the use of electronic portals encourages suppliers to ‘sharpen their pencils’ and provide the best prices in order to win work. Money is also saved as communication is digital (so there is no costs for paper and postage).

Time savings – electronic tools automate a lot of processes which saves time. An example of this is e-requisitioning tools where orders can be placed automatically by a piece of technology when quantities of a material reach a certain level. For example, in a cake manufacturing organisation they may use an MRP system which calculates how many eggs are required per day. The machine knows that when the company only have 50 eggs left, a new order needs to be issued to the supplier. The MRP system (e-requisitioning system) therefore saves time as the Procurement department doesn’t have to manually pick up the phone to place the order with the supplier- it is done automatically.

Access to higher levels of information - e-Procurement gives you centralised access to all your data. You can access the system to look at historical purchases with ease compared to having to dig through folders and filing cabinets. For example, an electronic PO system will hold details of all historical POs, this means if someone has a question about a PO that was raised 4 months ago, finding the information is much easier and quicker. Some systems may also be able to provide analytical data such as changes to spend over time, or which suppliers a buyer spends the most money with. This higher level of information can help inform upon future decision making. For example, if the organisation wishes to consolidate its supplier base it would look through historical data provided by the electronic system to find out which suppliers are used the least and remove these from the ‘pre-approved supplier list’. This level of data might not be available in manual systems.

Better budget tracking – using electronic systems allows for real-time information to be collected which allows Procurement Managers to see where spend is compared to forecasts and budgets. An example of this is in the use of Pre-Payment Cards – rather than giving staff members petty cash to make transactions and having to chase this up and collect receipts and change, a pre-payment card usually comes with an online portal where a manager can see what has been purchased and the remaining budget on that card for the month. A manager may be able to see for example that a member of staff has spend £300 of their allotted £500 monthly allowance.

Higher levels of transparency and control – using E-procurement tools allows an organisation to track who is ordering what. For example, an e-requisitioning tool may allow Procurement Assistants to make purchases up to £500 but set an automatic escalation if they try to buy something of higher value. This allows for Management to have greater levels of visibility and more control over spending. Another example of transparency and control is in the use of e-sourcing tools to run a competitive tender exercise. All communication between the buyer and suppliers is tracked on the system and award letters can be sent via the system too. This reduces the risk of information being lost.

Environmental benefits- the use of e-procurement tools means that there is less paperwork involved. For example, rather than creating a physical PO which needs to be signed by a manager, an electronic system can allow a manager to sign-off the purchase by clicking a button. This means there is no requirement for the document to be printed. This saves paper and thus has a positive on the environment. Using electronic systems may help an organisation achieve their environmental targets.

In conclusion there are numerous benefits for procurement to adopt e-procurement tools. Depending on the sector and requirements of each individualised company, some advantages may be more pertinent than others, but it is undeniable that technology is helping to shape the industry into a value adding function of organisations.

Tutor Notes

- With an essay like this you could use subheadings and number the advantages if you like. It’s a good idea to do one advantage per paragraph and using formatting really helps the examiner to read your essay.

- study guide p.108

(a) Five Procedures to Include in BetaCo’s Procurement Policy Manual

Purchase Requisition and Approval Procedure

All procurement requests must be formally submitted through standardized purchase requisition forms and approved by designated authorities before any purchase action is taken.

This ensures control over spending and adherence to budgets.

Supplier Selection and Evaluation Procedure

A structured process to identify, assess, and approve suppliers based on criteria such as quality, reliability, price, and compliance with BetaCo’s standards.

Supplier performance should be regularly reviewed to maintain quality and reliability.

Purchase Order (PO) Management Procedure

Clear guidelines on raising, issuing, and tracking purchase orders to suppliers, ensuring orders are placed only after necessary approvals and conform to agreed terms.

Purchase orders serve as formal contracts protecting both BetaCo and suppliers.

Invoice Processing and Payment Procedure

Defines steps for receiving, verifying, and authorizing supplier invoices, followed by timely payment according to agreed payment terms.

This avoids late payments and maintains good supplier relationships.

Conflict of Interest and Ethics Compliance Procedure

Policies requiring employees to declare any conflicts of interest and adhere to ethical standards in procurement activities to ensure transparency and fairness.

This prevents fraud, corruption, and protects BetaCo’s reputation.

(b) Analysis of How TWO Procedures Positively Influence Procurement Activities and Organisational Outcomes for BetaCo

1. Purchase Requisition and Approval Procedure

Positive Influence on Procurement Activities: Introducing a formal purchase requisition and approval procedure provides BetaCo with much-needed control and oversight over spending, addressing the current issue of overspending by project teams. It ensures that all procurement requests are validated against project budgets and company policies before any purchase commitment is made.

Impact on Organisational Outcomes: This procedure supports financial discipline and accountability, reducing uncontrolled expenditures and improving cost management. It also creates a clear audit trail for procurement decisions, helping senior management monitor and enforce compliance, thus reducing organisational risk.

2. Invoice Processing and Payment Procedure

Positive Influence on Procurement Activities: By implementing a standardized invoice verification and timely payment procedure, BetaCo can resolve the existing problem of late payments to suppliers. This ensures invoices are matched to purchase orders and delivery notes, approved promptly, and paid within agreed terms.

Impact on Organisational Outcomes: Timely payments strengthen supplier relationships, enhancing trust and reliability in supply continuity, which is critical for BetaCo’s growing customer base and production needs. It also helps avoid disputes or disruptions caused by delayed payments, contributing to smoother operations and better supplier cooperation.

Conclusion:

For BetaCo, incorporating structured procurement procedures into the policy manual is essential for centralising control, improving transparency, and reducing risks associated with decentralized procurement activities. Specifically, purchase requisition and approval alongside invoice processing procedures will directly address current challenges, leading to improved financial control, supplier relationships, and operational efficiency, ultimately supporting BetaCo’s growth ambitions and reputation.

When discussing capital expenditure (CapEx) and operational expenditure (OpEx) in the context of procurement and supply, it is essential to understand how they impact an organization ' s financial planning, decision-making, and procurement strategy. Below are five key differences between CapEx and OpEx:

1. Definition and Nature of Spend

Capital Expenditure (CapEx): Refers to investments made by a company to acquire, upgrade, or maintain physical assets such as property, machinery, or equipment. These are typically large, one-time purchases that provide long-term benefits.

Operational Expenditure (OpEx): Involves day-to-day expenses required to run the business, such as salaries, rent, utilities, and consumables. These costs are necessary for ongoing operations.

2. Accounting Treatment

CapEx: Considered a long-term investment, it is capitalized and recorded as an asset on the balance sheet. Depreciation or amortization is applied over the useful life of the asset.

OpEx: Fully expensed in the profit and loss statement in the accounting period in which it is incurred. It directly impacts the organization ' s profitability in the short term.

3. Budgeting and Approval Process

CapEx: Requires substantial financial planning, detailed justification, and approval from senior management due to its high-cost implications. It often involves long-term financial commitment.

OpEx: Generally included in the organization’s operating budget and does not require extensive approval processes, as it consists of routine expenses necessary for daily business functions.

4. Impact on Cash Flow and Financial Planning

CapEx: Affects cash flow significantly as it requires large upfront payments. Organizations often finance CapEx through loans, leasing, or long-term financial strategies.

OpEx: Represents smaller, recurring costs that are easier to manage and predict within the financial year, allowing for more flexibility in cash flow management.

5. Examples of Procurement and Supply Considerations

CapEx Examples: Purchasing manufacturing equipment, acquiring new office buildings, upgrading IT infrastructure (e.g., servers, data centers).

OpEx Examples: Office supplies, utility bills, employee salaries, maintenance and repair costs, software subscriptions.

Conclusion

Understanding the distinction between capital expenditure and operational expenditure is essential for procurement and supply professionals to make informed financial decisions, align with corporate strategy, and ensure efficient resource allocation. Procurement teams must consider factors such as cost-benefit analysis, funding sources, and long-term value when determining the best approach for an organization ' s spending strategy.

1) A definition of Value for Money: ensuring a purchase is cost effective. This may be that the purchase achieves the 5 Rights of Procurement or that the purchase achieves the 4Es: Economy, Efficiency, Effectiveness and Equity. – this is only worth 5 points, so don’t spend too long on this

2) 4 techniques Bob can use to achieve VFM: this is the bulk of your essay. Each of the 4 will be worth 5 points, so remember to give a thorough Explanation: and example. Pick 4 from the list below: complete a value analysis to eliminate non-essential features, minimise variety/ consolidate demand, avoid over specification, pro-active sourcing, whole life costing methodologies, eliminate / reduce inventory, use electronic systems, international sourcing, sustainability / environmental policies, currency/ exchange rate considerations, negotiating good payment terms, packaging, warrantees.

Example Essay:

" Value for money " (VFM) is a concept that refers to obtaining the best possible return on investment or benefits relative to the cost incurred. It involves assessing whether the goods, services, or activities provided offer an optimal balance between their cost and the quality, benefits, or outcomes they deliver. Value for money is not solely about choosing the cheapest option; instead, it considers the overall efficiency, effectiveness, and long-term value derived from an expenditure. For Bob, the Procurement Manager at ABC Ltd there are four key ways that he can achieve this for all future purchases.

Value Engineering

This is looking at the components of a product and evaluating the value of each component individually. You can then eliminate any components that do not add value to the end product. To do this Bob would choose a product to review and determine whether any parts of this can be omitted (thus saving the company money) or could be replaced by components that are of a higher quality at the same price (thus providing added value to the customer). For example, Bob could complete a Value Engineering exercise on the new mobile phone prototype ABC plan to release next year. His findings may discover a way to provide a higher quality camera at no additional cost or that some components don’t add value and can be eliminated.

Consolidate demand

Bob can achieve value for money by consolidating demand at ABC ltd. This would mean rather than each individual person/ department ordering what they want when they need it, Bob creates a centralised process for ordering items in bulk for the departments to share. For example, if each department require stationary to be ordered, Bob can consolidate this demand and create one big order each quarter. This will likely result in cost savings for ABC as suppliers often offer discounts for large orders. Moreover, consolidating demand will allow for saving in time (one person does the task once, rather than lots of people doing the same task and duplicating work).

International sourcing

Bob may find there is value for money in changing suppliers and looking at international sourcing. Often other countries outside of the UK can offer the same products at a lower cost. An example of this is manufactured goods from China. By looking at international supply chains, Bob may be able to make cost-savings for ABC. He should be sure that when using this technique there is no compromise on quality.

Whole Life Costing methodology

This is a technique Bob can use for procuring capital expenditure items for ABC. This involves looking at the costs of the item throughout its lifecycle and not just the initial purchase price. For example, if Bob needs to buy a new delivery truck he should consider not only the price of the truck, but also the costs of insurance for the truck, how expensive it is to buy replacement parts such as tyres and the cost of disposing of the truck once it reaches the end of its life. By considering these factors Bob will ensure that he buys the truck that represents the best value for money long term.

In conclusion Bob should ensure he uses these four techniques for all items he and his team procures in the future. This will ensure ABC Ltd are always achieving value for money, and thus remain competitive in the marketplace.

Tutor Notes

- This case study is really short, and the ones you’ll receive in the exam are often longer and give you more guidance on what they’re expecting you to write. With case study questions, you have to make your entire answer about Bob. So don’t bring in examples from your own experience, rather, focus on giving examples for Bob.

- A good rule of thumb for case study questions is make sure you reference the case study once per paragraph.

- Value for Money is a really broad topic and you can pretty much argue anything that procurement does is helping to achieve value for money. There’s a large table of stuff that’s considered VFM on p.38 but that table isn’t exhaustive. So feel free to come up with your own ideas for this type of essay.

Some additional tidbits of information on VFM:

- The ‘academic’ definition of Value for Money is ‘the optimum combination of whole life cost and the quality necessary to meet the customer’s requirement’

- Value for Money is an important strategic objective for most organisations but particularly in the public sector. This is because the public sector is financed by public money (taxes), so they must demonstrate that the organisation is using this money wisely. This might be an interesting fact to put into an essay on VFM.

- Value can often be hard to quantify, particularly in the service industry. E.g. in customer service it can be difficult to quantify the value of having knowledgeable and polite employees delivering the service.

A basic response would include:

- What a Corporate Governance Framework is - the system of rules, practices and processes which directs and controls a company. Corporate Governance refers to the way in which companies are governed and to what purpose.

- Impact this has on policies and processes – means the procurement department follows regulatory mechanisms (e.g. financial regulations, Codes of Practices), has a checks and balances system (such as auditing), uses e-procurement technologies, vets staff and suppliers, has a clear segregation of duties etc.

This is a very open question and there are so many correct answers. In fact, it’s quite hard to give a wrong answer to this question – as long as your response explains a policy or process that a procurement department can have that ensures they’re following Corporate Governance – that’s right!

A good response may mention:

- Corporate governance is in essence a ‘toolkit’ that allows an organisation to effectively manage itself, ensuring that it’s policies and procedures are compliant with legislation and are ethical. It also ensures that the company meets its objectives.

- The impact Corporate Governance has on the procurement department will be in mandating the ways in which goods and services are procured and in the general ways of working of the procurement department.

- In your response you should mention 5 (ish) different ways Corporate Governance would impact on how procurement do their job. Examples include:

- Ethical Conduct – corporate governance ensures that the company is operating in a legal and ethical way. This influences the processes Procurement will do and the type of suppliers they will engage with. This may also be in their approach to relationships and negotiations- seeking out collaborative relationships with suppliers rather than looking to exploit them. For example, an organisation that does not have a Corporate Governance structure may look to take advantage of suppliers and achieve the lowest cost possible at the expense of the supply chain and local community. An organisation that has strong Corporate Governance would work with suppliers, developing the relationships and thinking long-term about the impact on the local community. The organisation may therefore prioritise standards such as Fair Trade over price, and this would be reflected in the way tenders are evaluated by the procurement department.

- Use of Checks and Balance system- Corporate Governance ensures strong financial controls are implemented throughout the organisation. For the procurement department this may result in purchases being made to strict budgets (rather than just spending whatever they want), and business cases being written up and approved before the organisation spends a large amount of money on a single item. Another impact may be in the use of audits. For example, peer reviewing tenders and contract awards to ensue all members of the Procurement Team are following internal processes correctly.

- Anti-fraud prevention mechanisms. An important area of Corporate Governance is ensuring the organisation is free from fraud and corruption. This impacts on Procurement’s policies and processes as it will mean scrutinising tenders and who is being awarded contracts. It may result in high levels of Due Diligence being completed on suppliers before entering into contracts and providing a whistle-blowing service for staff to report issues.

- Security measures- this will be to protect the organisation from risk. It may include the procurement department vetting new staff by completing background checks. It may also involve the segregation of procurement duties so that no individual has too much power. E.g. one person raises the requisition and another person approves the purchase. Security may also be in ways of working such as password protecting documentation and limiting access to confidential information.

- Use of a Purchasing Policy Manual – this provides operational guidance on procurement policies and procedures to all staff members. It may detail things like who has permission to order what, who the Delegated Purchasing Authority (DPA) is and the roles and responsibilities of the team.

An excellent response may also include

- Reasons why Corporate Governance Frameworks impact on procurement policies and practices. This could include reasons of accountability, reputation and risk management, procurement’s links with other departments.

- You could also look at what processes would look like with Corporate Governance compared to without it (with CG = rule driven, autocratic but organisation is protected from risk. Without CG = laissez-faire, everyone does whatever they like, very risky)

- You could also provide further examples, either real life or hypothetical. Investopedia has some great information and examples you could use: Corporate Governance Definition: How It Works (investopedia.com)

How to approach the question

- There are 4 main components to this question that you will have to answer, so my advice is to first write down subheadings for your essay so you don’t miss any out: definition of supply chain management, drivers, advantages and disadvantages

- The question also brings up 2 concepts – supply chain management and tiered supply chains, it would be good to include a definition of both of these.

- Because of the number of things you’ll have to write, you don’t need to go into lots of detail – one paragraph per section will be enough.

Proposed Essay Structure

Intro – what is supply chain management and what is a tiered supply chain

P1 – drivers

P2 – advantages

P3 – disadvantages

Conclusion – supply chains are complex due to globalisation

Essay Ideas:

- Definition of supply chain management = Making something available in response to a buyer’s requirements. The transformation of goods from raw material into an end product (input > conversion > output)

- Drivers = Cost, Time/ Speed, Reliability, Responsiveness, Transparency, Globalisation

- Advantages = reduced costs by elimination of waste, improved responsiveness to customer requirements, joint-ventures with supply partners leading to innovations, tech sharing, improved communication leads to faster lead times for product development

- Disadvantages = needs considerable investment and internal support, closer relationships may be risky (IP, loss of control), issues in fairly distributing gains and risks

(you don’t need to talk about all of these- pick 1 or 2 you feel you know the best and focus on that)

Example Essay

Supply Chain Management (SCM) is the arrangement of processes involved in the production and distribution of goods / services - from the origin to the end consumer. In simple terms, it’s taking a raw product and transforming it into an end product that a consumer would purchase. For example taking a potato from a farmer, giving it to a manufacturer to make into chips and sending these to retailers to be sold. SCM relies on close relationships between the parties in the supply chain and adds value to the product at every stage. A Tiered Supply Chain is a specific configuration within SCM that involves multiple levels of suppliers and sub-suppliers. A buyer will work with a small amount of Tier 1 suppliers who will in turn work with their own suppliers. In a tiered system there can be many, many layers of suppliers who all ultimately work towards creating the same product. This essay aims to delve into the drivers, advantages, and disadvantages associated with implementing a complex supply chain, such as the Tiered Supply Chain model.

The main drivers of using a tiered supply chain are often rooted in the pursuit of efficiency, cost-effectiveness, and flexibility. By consolidating suppliers into distinct tiers, organizations can streamline their management processes, reduce complexity, and enhance overall supply chain performance. Additionally, tiered supply chains are often employed in response to the global nature of modern business, accommodating the need to source materials and components from various regions while maintaining a manageable and responsive supply network.

One of the advantages of a Tiered Supply Chain is the streamlined management of suppliers. In this model, there are fewer direct suppliers to oversee, simplifying the coordination and communication processes. This can lead to increased efficiency and responsiveness as organizations deal with a smaller, more manageable pool of suppliers. The consolidation of suppliers in a tiered system may also result in potential cost savings and improved collaboration with a select group of trusted partners.

However, the complexity of a Tiered Supply Chain brings disadvantages. One significant drawback is reduced visibility. As the supply chain extends across multiple tiers, organizations may struggle to have a comprehensive view of the entire process. This lack of visibility can lead to challenges in tracking and responding to potential disruptions. Moreover, ethical risks emerge when companies have limited oversight over lower-tier suppliers, potentially exposing organizations to issues such as labour exploitation, environmental concerns, or violations of ethical standards.

In conclusion, supply chain management has evolved into a complex discipline due to the forces of globalization and consumer demands for speed and quality. The Tiered Supply Chain model, driven by these factors, presents both advantages and disadvantages. While managing fewer suppliers can enhance efficiency, the trade-off includes diminished visibility and increased ethical risks. Organizations must carefully evaluate the specific needs of their operations and weigh the benefits against the challenges when deciding whether to adopt a Tiered Supply Chain. In this intricate landscape, the ability to balance complexity and efficiency becomes paramount for sustained success in the global marketplace.

Tutor Notes

- Definition of supply chain management is from p.5

- Drivers, advantages and disadvantages p.9

- This topic used to be much more in depth in the old syllabus and has been drastically simplified in the new study guide. The guide is actually quite light on this topic stating simply that “globalisation and localisation are both drivers of using supply chain tiering”. If you don’t work in manufacturing, or an industry that uses supply chain tiering, this concept may be a bit alien to you and I’d recommend doing a little extra research. The best example of supply chain tiering is in car manufacturing- and that would be a good example to use in an essay. Some additional links for research:

- Supplier Tiers: What ' s The Difference Between Tier 1, Tier 2, and Tier 3 | PLANERGY Software

- Sustainable Sourcing - Definition, Examples, Benefits & Best Practices (brightest.io)

- https://youtu.be/fs1rDgBQy1M

How to approach this question

- This question is testing to see if you know the 4 procurement procedures allowed in the Public Sector which are: open, restricted, competitive dialogue, competitive dialogue with negotiation. The Public Sector is limited in how it can procure due to the Public Contract Regulations, so things like Early Supplier Involvement isn’t an option.

- The question doesn’t specifically say it has to be these four, but these are the ones in the book. Because of the vagueness you could say something like running a competition and awarding via a Framework instead. Talking about Public Private Partnerships could also be appropriate but that is outside of the scope of this module (and Level! It comes up in Level 5). These answers would be accepted.

- Also note that it doesn’t say the UK in the question, so if you answered this about your own country, that would be fine.

Example Essay

Each country’s government has its own regulations relating to how goods, services and works can be procured. The UK’s procurement rules is currently dictated by the Public Procurement Regulations 2015 which is based off EU Procurement Directives. This piece of legislation will likely be superseded in Autumn 2023 due to the UK leaving the EU. Until this point, the PCR allows UK public sector organisations to procure in the following ways: open, restricted, competitive dialogue, competitive dialogue with negotiation

Open Procedure: This is the most straightforward and transparent method. A local government issues an open tender for office supplies. Any company that provides these supplies can submit a bid. The government then evaluates all bids based on price, quality, and delivery terms to select the supplier. Any interested supplier can submit a tender. The process is open from the outset, and all submissions are evaluated against pre-defined criteria. This procedure is used when you wish to attract a large number of bidders for the opportunity and is often posted online on a platform such as Find A Tender.com so that suppliers can find the opportunity. If it is a large contract it is a requirement for details to be published on OJEU. The disadvantage of using this approach is that you may receive many bids which can be time-consuming.

Restricted Procedure: In this method, the public sector organization invites suppliers to express their interest. After a preliminary selection process, only those who meet the criteria are invited to submit tenders. This is used when the opportunity is more technical, for example a healthcare authority needs specialized medical equipment. The authority would requests expressions of interest from suppliers. After reviewing these, it invites a shortlist of qualified suppliers to submit detailed bids for further evaluation. The benefit of this approach is that unsuitable suppliers are weeded out early, this saving time.

Competitive Dialogue: This is used for complex contracts where the organization cannot define the technical means or legal or financial make-up of a project in advance. A dialogue with selected bidders is conducted to develop one or more suitable solutions, which are then put out to tender. For example, a local council is planning a new public transport system but is unsure of the best solution. It enters into a dialogue with several firms specializing in transport systems to explore various options before requesting final bids based on the developed solutions. Suppliers can be eliminated through the dialogue process based on pre-determined criteria.

Competitive Dialogue with Negotiation: Similar to competitive dialogue, but with an added phase of negotiation. It ' s used for particularly complex projects where the needs cannot be met without adaptation of readily available solutions. For example: a government department requires a complex IT system that integrates various existing systems. It engages in a competitive dialogue to develop potential solutions and then negotiates with bidders to refine these solutions before finalizing the contract. This procedure allows for negotiations with the winning bidder to readjust requirements if needed.

The approach taken by a public sector organisation will depend on a number of factors, but in particular the complexity of the project and whether there is a pre-determined scope. Other factors to consider include; the time-sensitiveness of the project and how quickly the procurement exercise needs to be completed, the amount of suppliers in the marketplace, and whether suppliers need to be consulted on to create the specification.

Tutor Notes

- These four procedures are outlined on p.212. Post PCR 2015, these procedures may change, or be renamed, depending on what the UK government decide to do. So if you’re taking this exam in November 2024 or later, note that the study guide is now out of date and you should conduct a bit of your own research.

- You could also mention that the value of spend is a factor when public sector organisations are deciding on a procurement route. For really low value stuff, like they need a new sofa for the office, most organisation ' s requirements are to get three quotes and compare them. That isn ' t in the study guide, it ' s just real life (I ' ve worked in this sector so know this stuff). Each organisation will have it ' s own thresholds for what procurement route needs to be taken, so I wouldn ' t comment on that but generally if it ' s under £10k there ' s quite a bit of flexibility. Where you reach ' threshold ' then things become very serious and there ' s much more scrutiny.

- Thresholds are not part of the syllabus so don ' t worry about learning this. But if you ' re interested have a read here: New public procurement thresholds from 1 January 2024 - BM Insights - Blake Morgan

How to approach this question

- The first question can be a simple introduction with a bit of extra detail. The main ‘meat’ to your essay is going to be explaining the three sectors, their characteristics and example businesses.

- Aim for three well explained characteristics as a minimum

Example essay

An industry sector refers to a broad category or grouping of businesses and economic activities that share similar characteristics and functions in the production and distribution of goods and services. These sectors are often classified into three main categories: Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary. Here are the main characteristics and types of businesses you will find in each of these industry sectors:

1. Primary Sector:

• Characteristics: The primary sector involves activities related to the extraction and production of raw materials and natural resources directly from the environment. This sector relies on nature and weather patterns: businesses in the primary sector are highly dependent on natural factors such as climate, weather, soil quality, and geographic location. These factors can significantly impact the productivity and profitability of primary sector activities. Extreme weather such as floods can severely impact this sector. Moreover there is a seasonality to this sector and many activities in the primary sector require a significant amount of manual labour, particularly in agriculture, fishing, and forestry. However, modern technology has also been integrated into some primary sector activities to increase efficiency.

• Types of Businesses: a. Agriculture: This includes farming, crop cultivation, livestock raising, and forestry. b. Mining and Extraction. c. Fishing and Aquaculture: Forestry and Logging: Includes the harvesting of timber and related activities.

2. Secondary Sector:

• Characteristic: The secondary sector focuses on the transformation of raw materials and intermediate goods into finished products. The main characteristic of the sector is that it requires high levels of machinery and industrial techniques. There is a reliance on technology. Secondly, the secondary sector adds significant value to the products compared to their raw material form. This value addition is achieved through processing, assembly, and quality control processes. The third main characteristic is standardisation: Manufacturing processes often involve standardization of components and processes to ensure consistency and quality in the final products. Standardization helps in economies of scale.

• Types of Businesses: a. Manufacturing: This sector includes factories and plants that produce tangible goods such as automobiles, electronics, textiles, and machinery. b. Construction: Involves the building and construction of structures like buildings, bridges, and infrastructure. c. Utilities: Companies providing essential services like electricity, gas, and water supply fall into this category.

3. Tertiary Sector:

• Characteristic: The tertiary sector is also known as the service sector and involves businesses that offer various services to consumers and other businesses. The main defining characteristic of this sector is Intangibility: Services are intangible and cannot be touched or held. They are often experienced directly by consumers through interactions with service providers or through the use of technology. Secondly, High Human Involvement: The tertiary sector relies heavily on a skilled and often highly educated workforce to deliver services effectively. This can include professionals such as doctors, lawyers, teachers, and customer service representatives. Lastly, Customization: Many services are customized to meet the specific needs and preferences of individual clients or customers. This personalization is a key characteristic of the tertiary sector. For example Legal Advice will always be different depending on the specific needs of the client.

• Types of Businesses: a. Retail and Wholesale: Businesses engaged in the sale of goods to consumers or to other businesses. b. Healthcare and Education: This includes hospitals, clinics, schools, colleges, and universities. c. Financial Services: Banks, insurance companies, and investment firms are part of this sector. d. Hospitality and Tourism: Hotels, restaurants, travel agencies, and entertainment venues fall into this category. e. Professional Services: Legal, accounting, consulting, and IT services are part of the tertiary sector.

These industry sectors represent the different stages of economic activity, with the primary sector providing raw materials, the secondary sector processing and manufacturing goods, and the tertiary sector offering services and distribution. Together, these sectors form the backbone of an economy, contributing to its growth and development

Tutor Notes

- I ' ve gone overboard on naming the types of organisation in the different sectors. You don ' t have to remember all of these. 3 examples is sufficient to get good marks. I ' ve just named them all so you can see what could be considered a right answer.

- Some people are talking about Quaternary and Quinary Sectors. CIPS is not one of those people, so don’t worry if you come across those terms in any further reading. But FYI

1.

• Quaternary Sector: This sector involves knowledge-based activities, including research and development, information technology, and data analysis.

• Quinary Sector: The quinary sector comprises high-level decision-making and leadership roles in areas such as government, academia, healthcare, and top-level corporate management.

- LO 4.1 p.196

How to approach this question:

- This is quite an open question and there are many different things you could mention. One way to approach it would be to use Carter’s 10 Cs- discuss a couple of these. OR just give a couple of criteria in different paragraphs. Some ideas include: Supplier financial status, Reputation / References, Quality, Availability, CSR Policies / Ethics / Environmental considerations, Accreditations, Added Value. This list is not exhaustive.

- If you’re going for Carter’s 10 Cs you could name a couple of these: competency, consistency, capability, control, cost, cash, clean, communication, culture, commitment

- I don’t think either approach is better or worse. Choose the criteria you know the most about and write about those.

- The question doesn’t tell you how many criteria to name, so you have to make a judgement call here. I would aim for 5-6. But if you can only remember 4 that’s fine. The main thing they’re looking for is that you explain for each one 1) what it is 2) how procurement can check 3) why procurement would look at that criteria 4) an example. If you do too many you risk not going into enough detail on each. It’s a balance. 5 is always a good number to aim for if the question doesn’t state.

Example Essay

In the procurement cycle, the supplier selection phase is a critical juncture that demands consideration. Procurement Managers shoulder the responsibility of identifying and awarding contracts to suppliers who not only meet immediate needs, but contribute to the long-term success of the organization. This essay explores various criteria a Procurement Manager can employ to ensure the selection of the best supplier: financial stability, reputation, quality, availability, CSR policies, and added value.

Financial stability is a foundational criterion in supplier selection. Assessing a supplier ' s financial status involves a multifaceted evaluation, with liquidity and gearing ratio taking center stage. The acid test, comparing short-term assets to liabilities, offers insights into a supplier ' s ability to settle debts promptly, with a ratio exceeding 1 indicating financial health. Meanwhile, the gearing ratio, reflecting the proportion of capital funded by loans, aids in gauging financial risk, with a ratio below 50% considered low-risk. Relying on published Profit and Loss statements and income statements, along with financial credit checks from platforms like Dun and Bradstreet, empowers Procurement Managers to make informed decisions. This financial scrutiny is imperative to avoid entering contracts with suppliers facing imminent financial struggles, safeguarding against potential disruptions to the supply chain.

Reputation and references are another pivotal criterion. Seeking references from previous contracts allows Procurement Managers to gauge a supplier ' s track record in successfully delivering on similar commitments. Independent reviews and informal market inquiries supplement this information, providing a holistic understanding of a supplier ' s performance. However, caution is advised in overreliance on past performance, as variables like personnel changes or contract scale differences may impact outcomes. Recognizing that past shortcomings may have been addressed internally further emphasizes the need for a balanced approach to reference evaluation.

Thirdly, Quality. Beyond the product itself, considerations extend to the supplier ' s technological capabilities, manufacturing processes, and relevant accreditations such as ISO 9001. Physical visits to supplier sites may be warranted, especially for products like raw materials where samples can be requested. Adhering to recognized safety standards and assessing factors like fire retardancy ensures that the quality of manufactured goods aligns with established benchmarks.

Next, Availability is another important criteria to consider. Procurement Managers must evaluate a supplier ' s capacity and capability to meet specific requirements. Inquiries about existing contracts and flexibility in response to demand fluctuations provide insights into a supplier ' s commitment and responsiveness. Assessing the supplier ' s workload and the significance of the buyer in their client portfolio helps determine the level of attention and service the buyer can expect. A buyer may wish to avoid working for a supplier who is already stretched very thinly with other contracts.

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) policies and ethical considerations have gained prominence in supplier selection. Beyond legal compliance, Procurement Managers may scrutinize a supplier ' s history for convictions or negative press related to corruption, bribery, or fraud. The presence of a Modern Slavery Policy and Environmental Policy, along with relevant accreditations like ISO14001 or Fair Trade certification, attests to a supplier ' s commitment to ethical and sustainable practices. Procurement would likely seek to appoint a supplier who’s CSR vision aligns with their own company’s.

Lastly, added value is an important criteria to consider. This is particularly so for Public Sector Organizations governed by the Social Value Act. In addition to meeting contractual requirements, suppliers may offer knowledge sharing, training, improved processes, or contribute to social value by employing local community members or providing apprenticeships. This criterion aligns procurement decisions with broader organizational goals, enhancing the overall impact of supplier relationships and benefitting the local community.

In conclusion, a careful combination of financial scrutiny, reputation assessment, quality evaluation, availability considerations, CSR policies, and added value analysis forms the bedrock of effective supplier selection in the procurement cycle. Procurement Managers, armed with a holistic understanding of these criteria, should seek not only to fulfil immediate needs, but also consider the long-term impact of supplier appointments.

Tutor Notes

- A ‘good’ scoring answer (50-70%) will explain the criteria well and give examples. If you’re looking for a distinction level answer (70% +) you could also mention advantages, disadvantages and risks associated with each of the criteria. For example, when looking at references and reputation it’s important to know that a supplier would only ever provide a good reference to you, they would never tell you of a contract that failed. Another example is that financial data may be skewed- a supplier may have a low score if they are just starting up or have recently remortgaged a property. It’s therefore important to get a commentary as well as the figures / scores.

- You could also mention that criteria could be weighted e.g. more importance given to quality than financial status and also consider how easy or difficult it would be to get the information e.g. a supplier may say they have lots of availability to deliver the service you require, but they may just be saying this to win business. How do you know for sure?

- Social Value Act isn’t in this syllabus. If you work in Public Sector procurement it’s something you’ll be very familiar with. If you don’t or you’re outside of the UK do not worry about this. I’ve just included it to show how you can bring in your own knowledge to questions like this. You could think of particular criteria that’s important to your industry and write about that. The Social Value Act: What is it, and why is it important? (samtaler.co.uk)

- Study guide p.77

Electronica Manufacturing

Jane Henderson has been brought in to set up and lead a new procurement department at Electronica Manufacturing. It manufactures

a range of electronic products, components and sub-assemblies for clients in the Information technology sector.

Jane has carried out an initial analysis of procurement practices and has discovered that the company has never focused on how

procurement tools and techniques can be used to reduce costs. She is also keen to improve procurement added value, increase quality

and increase end-user satisfaction.

Jane wishes to introduce a more robust approach to procurement and is considering implementing new processes and procedures in

the procurement of raw materials and sub-assemblies.

Using the CIPS Procurement Cycle to Influence Spend on Raw Materials, Deliver Cost Reductions, and Enable Value Benefits

Electronica Manufacturing has historically not focused on procurement’s role in cost reduction or added value. By implementing the CIPS Procurement Cycle, Jane Henderson can establish a structured and strategic procurement process to optimize spend on raw materials, achieve cost reductions, and generate other value benefits. Below is a detailed analysis of how each stage of the CIPS Procurement Cycle can support these goals:

1. Understanding Needs and Developing Specifications

How it Helps:

Jane must assess raw material requirements based on product designs, production needs, and customer expectations.

Avoiding over-specification ensures that materials are fit for purpose rather than unnecessarily costly.

Impact on Electronica Manufacturing:

Prevents unnecessary spending on premium materials that don’t add value.

Ensures cost-effective sourcing without compromising quality.

2. Market Analysis and Supplier Identification

How it Helps:

Conducting supplier market research helps identify competitive suppliers offering better pricing and quality.

Analyzing market trends (e.g., commodity price fluctuations) allows for timely purchasing to mitigate cost increases.

Impact on Electronica Manufacturing:

Reduces costs by sourcing from cost-effective and reliable suppliers.

Identifies potential new suppliers that offer better value and innovation.

3. Developing a Sourcing Strategy

How it Helps:

Jane can implement strategic sourcing, using techniques like long-term contracts, supplier partnerships, and competitive bidding.

A well-defined strategy ensures that procurement aligns with business goals.

Impact on Electronica Manufacturing:

Reduces supply chain risks by diversifying suppliers.

Maximizes cost savings through bulk purchasing and supplier negotiations.

4. Supplier Evaluation and Selection

How it Helps:

A structured evaluation process ensures selection based on cost, quality, reliability, and sustainability.

Supplier benchmarking and total cost analysis ensure best-value sourcing.

Impact on Electronica Manufacturing:

Reduces waste and costs by selecting suppliers that provide consistent quality.

Helps mitigate supply chain risks, ensuring reliable raw material availability.

5. Contract Management and Negotiation

How it Helps:

Jane can introduce structured contracts with cost-control mechanisms, such as fixed pricing, volume discounts, and service-level agreements (SLAs).

Contract negotiation can lock in competitive pricing and ensure supplier accountability.

Impact on Electronica Manufacturing:

Improves cost predictability and budget control.

Strengthens supplier relationships, leading to better terms and cost efficiencies.

6. Purchase Order Processing and Expediting

How it Helps:

Implementing an efficient purchase order (PO) system reduces administrative inefficiencies and speeds up raw material procurement.

Use of automated procurement systems (e.g., ERP systems) ensures cost-effective order processing.

Impact on Electronica Manufacturing:

Reduces administrative overheads and human errors.

Ensures faster lead times and better inventory control, reducing stock shortages and excess inventory costs.

7. Supplier Relationship Management (SRM)

How it Helps:

Establishing collaborative relationships with key suppliers can drive joint cost-saving initiatives.

Long-term supplier partnerships can lead to better pricing, innovation, and risk-sharing.

Impact on Electronica Manufacturing:

Reduces costs through supplier-led efficiency improvements.

Encourages supplier innovation, leading to better materials and higher-quality products.

8. Performance Review and Supplier Development

How it Helps:

Regular supplier performance reviews ensure that quality, cost, and delivery expectations are met.

Supplier development programs can help underperforming suppliers improve efficiency, reducing procurement risks.

Impact on Electronica Manufacturing:

Improves product quality and consistency, reducing defects and waste-related costs.

Enhances supplier accountability, leading to more cost-effective procurement.

9. Risk Management and Compliance

How it Helps:

Jane can introduce risk management strategies such as dual sourcing, inventory buffers, and price hedging to mitigate supply chain disruptions.

Ensuring compliance with ethical, legal, and sustainability standards reduces long-term operational risks.

Impact on Electronica Manufacturing:

Reduces financial and operational risks, improving business continuity.

Strengthens brand reputation by ensuring ethical sourcing.

10. Procurement and Supply Strategy Review

How it Helps:

Continuous evaluation of procurement strategies ensures alignment with changing market conditions and company goals.

Data-driven decision-making through spend analysis and procurement reporting allows for ongoing cost optimizations.

Impact on Electronica Manufacturing:

Enhances procurement efficiency and sustains cost reductions.

Ensures procurement remains a value-adding function rather than a cost center.

Conclusion

By applying the CIPS Procurement Cycle, Jane Henderson can transform Electronica Manufacturing’s procurement function from an ad-hoc, cost-inefficient process into a strategic, value-driven function. This structured approach will enable smarter spending on raw materials, continuous cost reductions, and broader business benefits, such as improved quality, efficiency, and stakeholder satisfaction.

Implementing procurement best practices will not only reduce costs but also drive long-term business sustainability and competitive advantage.

Essay Plan:

Definition of Stakeholder- someone who has a ‘stake’ or interest in the company. A person or organisation who influences and can be influenced by the company.

Categories of stakeholders:

1) Internal Stakeholders- these people work inside the company e.g. employees, managers etc

2) Connected- these people work with the company e.g. suppliers, mortgage lenders

3) External Stakeholders – these people are outside of the company e.g. the government, professional bodies, the local community.

Example Essay:

A stakeholder is an individual, group, or entity that has a vested interest or concern in the activities, decisions, or outcomes of an organization or project. Stakeholders are those who can be affected by or can affect the organization, and they play a crucial role in influencing its success, sustainability, and reputation. Understanding and managing stakeholder relationships is a fundamental aspect of effective organizational governance and decision-making and there are several different types of stakeholders.

Firstly, internal stakeholders are those individuals or groups directly connected to the daily operations and management of the organization. Internal stakeholders are key to success and are arguably more vested in the company succeeding. They may depend on the company for their income / livelihood. Anyone who contributes to the company ' s internal functions can be considered an internal stakeholder for example:

This category includes

1) Employees: With a direct influence on the organization ' s success, employees are critical internal stakeholders. Their engagement, satisfaction, and productivity impact the overall performance.

2) Management and Executives: The leadership team has a significant influence on the organization ' s strategic direction and decision-making. Their decisions can shape the company ' s future.

Secondly, connected stakeholders are those individuals or groups whose interests are tied to the organization but may not be directly involved in its day-to-day operations. Connected stakeholders work alongside the organisation and often have a contractual relationship with the organisation. For example, banks, mortgage lenders, and suppliers. These stakeholders have an interest in the business succeeding, but not as much as internal stakeholders. It is important to keep these stakeholders satisfied as the organisation does depend on them to some extent. For example, it is important that the organisation has a good relationship with their bank / mortgage provider/ supplier as failing to pay what they owe may result in the stakeholders taking legal action against the organisation.

This category includes:

1) Shareholders/Investors: Holding financial stakes in the organization, shareholders seek a return on their investment and have a vested interest in the company ' s financial performance.

2) Suppliers and Partners: External entities providing goods, services, or collaboration. Their relationship with the organization impacts the quality and efficiency of its operations.

Lastly external stakeholders are entities outside the organization that can influence or be influenced by its actions. This category includes anyone who is affected by the company but who does not contribute to internal operations. They have less power to influence decisions than internal and connected stakeholders. External stakeholders include the government, professional bodies, pressure groups and the local community. They have quite diverse objectives and have varying ability to influence the organisation. For example, the government may be able to influence the organisation by passing legislation that regulates the industry but they do not have the power to get involved in the day-to-day affairs of the company. Pressure groups may have varying degrees of success in influencing the organisation depending on the subject matter. This category includes:

1) Customers: With a direct impact on the organization ' s revenue, customers are vital external stakeholders. Their satisfaction and loyalty are crucial for the company ' s success.

2) Government and Regulatory Bodies: External entities overseeing industry regulations. Compliance with these regulations is crucial for the organization ' s reputation and legal standing.

In conclusion, stakeholders are diverse entities with a vested interest in an organization ' s activities. The three categories—internal, connected and external —encompass various groups that significantly influence and are influenced by the organization. Recognizing and addressing the needs and concerns of stakeholders are vital for sustainable and responsible business practices.

Tutor Notes

- The above essay is pretty short and to the point and would pass. If you want to beef out the essay you can include some of the following information for a higher score:

- Stakeholders can be harmed by, or benefit from the organisation (can affect and be affected by the organisation). For example a stakeholder can be harmed if the organisation becomes involved in illegal or immoral practices- e.g. the local community can suffer if the organisation begins to pollute the local rivers. The local community can also benefit from the organisation through increased employment levels.

- CSR argues organisations should respect the rights of stakeholder groups

- Stakeholders are important because they may have direct or indirect influence on decisions

- The public sector has a wider and more complex range of stakeholders as they’re managed on behalf of society as a whole. They’re more likely to take a rage of stakeholder views into account when making decisions. However, these stakeholders are less powerful – i.e. they can’t threaten market sanctions, to withdraw funding, or to quit the business etc.

- The essay doesn’t specifically ask you to Map Stakeholders, but you could throw in a cheeky mention of Mendelow’s Stakeholder Matrix, perhaps in the conclusion. Don’t spend time describing it though- you won’t get more than 1 point for mentioning it. You’d be better off spending your time giving lots and lots of examples of different types of stakeholders.

- Study guide p. 58

How to approach this question:

- The Sourcing Cycle is the first half of the CIPS Procurement Cycle and includes these steps:

1) Define Business Need

2) Market Analysis + Make vs Buy

3) Develop Strategy and Plan

4) Pre-Procurement Market Testing

5) Develop Documents and Specification

6) Supplier Selection

7) Issue Tender

8) Bid Evaluation

9) Contract Award and Implementation

Your response should detail 5 of these. It is a good idea to pick the ones you know most about and where there is more to write about. You won’t get any extra points for naming more than 5 so focus on getting as much detail down about 5, rather than explaining more of them.

Essay Plan

Introduction – explain what the sourcing cycle is – the stages of the procurement cycle before a contract is signed. It describes the steps an organisation will take to source/ procures goods or services.

Paragraph 1 – Define the business need

· How is the need identified? E.g. by end user, stores department, ERP system.

· Procurement should challenge this – is it really necessary? Suggest alternatives – this could be a key source of added value

· Put together business case / requisition / project initiation document

· What type of purchase? Straight rebuy, modified rebuy, new purchase

· Decide on what type of specification would be best - Conformance vs performance specification

· This stage may include early supplier involvement

Paragraph 2 – Market Analysis and Make vs Buy Decision

· Create an Analysis by segmenting the market by buyer, product, distribution channel, geography, customer market etc.

· Make vs Buy - use Carter’s Matrix to decide whether the organisation should make vs buy.

· Also consider outsourcing at this stage

Paragraph 3 – Documents and Specification

· Draft documents. These may include a RFQ or ITT, a specification and a proposed form of contract

· Specification may be conformance or performance based

· A contract sets out the roles, rights, responsibilities and obligations of the parties and shows intention to enter into ‘legal relations’

· This stage defines the ‘offer’ which becomes binding once other party accepts

· Documentation may also include proposed KPIs and SLAs

Paragraph 4 – Supplier Selection

· For a new purchase, supplier selection is very important - investigation should be proportionate to the value of the procurement. For rebuys or low-risk purchases you could use the same supplier or a list of pre-approved suppliers.

· You can locate potential suppliers by; catalogues, websites, trade registers, market exchanges and review sites, trade or industry press, fairs and conferences, networking and recommendations/ referrals.

· You can shortlist suppliers by sending out a pre-qualification questionnaire. This adds value by reducing wasted time / costs / risks to entering into a contract with the wrong supplier.

· Other criteria for supplier selection include using Carter’s 10 Cs (competency, consistency, capability, control, cost, cash, clean, communication, culture, commitment), the supplier’s financial standing (e.g. liquidity and gearing), references and considering their CSR policy.

Paragraph 5 – Issue Tender

· Competitive bidding should only be done when there’s sufficient time and resources available, there’s sufficient suppliers in the marketplace, they’re keen to win business (ie that there’s appetite for competition) and there is a strong specification

· Best practice is to issue tenders electronically as it ensures equal treatment of suppliers and transparency

· Consider open vs closed procurement processes

· Use a cross-functional team – particularly when marking responses

Conclusion – you could mention here that different sourcing activities may require more or less effort at each of the stages e.g. procuring a new item may require more market analysis than a re-buy.

Tutor Notes:

- If you want to add in extra details, you could think about ways procurement can add value at each stage

- In the old syllabus, CIPS were a bit obsessed with Michael Porter. In the Market Analysis bit you could talk about using Porter’s 5 forces (buyer and supplier power, threat of new entrants, threat of substitutions, supplier rivalry) and Porter’s 3 generic strategies for competing (cost leadership, differentiation, niche segment). This has been removed from the study guide so it’s not essential to know this for this module, but if you’ve seen it before it’s a nice one to throw in.

- You could also mention that there are differences between the public and private sector procurement at the different stages. E.g. Public Sector requires open competitions for contracts of a certain value and must follow the rules set out in Public Contract Regulations – the private sector doesn’t have such strict regulations so there is much more flexibility in how tenders are completed. Also in the public sector, the evaluation criteria needs to be agreed beforehand and presented in the ITT- not the same for the private sector.

- Study guide p.71