L4M2 Defining Business Needs Questions and Answers

Detailed Explanation:

B (Limited number of suppliers): Fewer suppliers lead to higher bargaining power due to reduced competition.

E (Urgent buyer requirement): Suppliers gain leverage when buyers have limited time to source alternatives.

Education on markets and buyer size are factors that strengthen buyer, not supplier, bargaining power. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Supplier Negotiation and Market Power.

Explanation

Regression refers to a quantitative measure of the relationship between one or more independent variables and a resulting dependent variable. Regression is of use to professionals in a wide range of fields from science and public service to financial analysis.

To perform a regression analysis, a statistician collects a set of data points, each including a com-plete set of dependent and independent variables. For example, the dependent variable could be a firm’s stock price and the independent variables could be the Standard and Poor’s 500 index and the national unemployment rate, assuming that the stock is not listed in the S&P 500. The sample set could be each of these three data sets for the past 20 years.

On a chart, these data points would appear as scatter plot, a set of points that may or may not appear to be organized along any line. If a linear pattern is apparent, it may be possible to sketch a line of best fit that minimizes the distance of those points from that line. If no organizing axis is visually apparent, regression analysis can generate a line based on the least squares method. This method builds the line which minimizes the squared distance of each point from the line of best fit.

Line of best fit is one of the most important outputs of regression analysis.

Detailed Explanation:

A (Early supplier involvement): Engaging suppliers early fosters innovation by leveraging their expertise in developing solutions.

D (Outcome-based specification): Focusing on outcomes rather than rigid inputs encourages creative and flexible proposals.Conformance specifications (C) restrict innovation, and standards (E) limit supplier flexibility. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Innovation in Procurement Specifications.

Explanation

Every sector among the options requires intensive capital investment. However, only manufacturing and retails bury much of their working capital in form of inventory. Raw materials and WIP only present in manufacturing sector.

The manufacturing industry is undergoing massive change, rivaling the Industrial Revolution that began in England and continued on Detroit's assembly lines. But today’s revolution is “smart,” thanks to factories using artificial intelligence and robots.

A new trend is the “cobot” — a collaborative robot designed to work with humans. One company called Moduform uses them to make furniture in the U.S. The company credits using cobots for reducing their staffing turnover, since the robots do mundane repetitive tasks that bore humans, while people can now do cognitive tasks requiring judgment and diversified responsibilities. Other innovations include 3D printing, Artificial Intelligence and automation.

Today’s artificial intelligence manufacturing revolution improves performance in two key areas of manufacturing: productivity and quality control.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2: Cost Management)

CIPS teaches that effective buyers conduct cost breakdowns that include both direct and indirect costs, using data from:

Supplier financial reports,

Benchmarking,

Industry cost models.

Thus, buyers can analyse indirect costs (e.g. overheads, utilities, admin) to strengthen negotiation positions.

Relevant CIPS L4M2 Sections:

Cost analysis and supplier price build-up

Using cost data to negotiate value

Explanation

According to Investopedia, the financial services sector provides financial services to people and corporations. This segment of the economy is made up of a variety of financial firms includ-ing banks, investment houses, lenders, finance companies, real estate brokers, and insurance com-panies. As noted above, the financial services industry is probably the most important sector of the economy, leading the world in terms of earnings and equity market capitalization. Large conglomerates dominate this sector, but it also includes a diverse range of smaller companies.

According to the finance and development department of the International Monetary Fund (IMF), financial services are the processes by which consumers or businesses acquire financial goods. For example, a payment system provider offers a financial service when it accepts and transfers funds between payers and recipients. This includes accounts settled through credit and debit cards, checks, and electronic funds transfers.

Companies in the financial services industry manage money. For instance, a financial advi-sor manages assets and offers advice on behalf of a client. The advisor does not directly provide investments or any other product, rather, they facilitate the movement of funds between savers and the issuers of securities and other instruments. This service is a temporary task rather than a tangible asset.

Financial goods, on the other hand, are not tasks. They are things. A mortgage loan may seem like a service, but it's actually a product that lasts beyond the initial provision. Stocks, bonds, loans, commodity assets, real estate, and insurance policies are examples of financial goods.

Explanation

Technical standards are often produced by a national or international body such as British Standard Institute (BSI)

LO 3, AC 3.1

Detailed Explanation:

A (Customer payment upon purchase): Immediate payments improve cash flow.

D (Loan): Loans provide cash inflow, though they may increase liabilities.Options like supplier payment on receipt (C) negatively impact cash flow, and sales promotions (B) may increase expenses. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Financial Management in Procurement.

Explanation

Value engineering is often applied to new products or services. Early supplier involvement (ESI) is the involvement of a supplier in the product development process from a very stage in order to use the supplier's experience and expertise. ESI can bring cost reduction opportunities, process improvements, supply chain improvements and reduce supply risk. Both processes focus on development of new product or service. They tend to work the best if they are used together.

LO 3, AC 3.1 & AC 3.4

Explanation

Value Analysis (VA) is concerned with existing products. It involves a current product being ana-lysed and evaluated by a team, to reduce costs, improve product function or both. Value Analysis exercises use a plan which step-by-step, methodically evaluates the product in a range of areas. These include costs, function, alternative components and design aspects such as ease of manufac-ture and assembly.

According to the Value Methodology standard, there are 6 phases to a Value Analysis:

- Information

- Function Analysis

- Creative

- Evaluation

- Development

- Presentation

1. Information

In this first phase, the team attempts to understand why the project exists and who or what it is to produce. They obtain project data, present the original design or product concepts, and understand the project scope. Schedule, costs, budget, risk, and other non-monetary issues are studied until the team is comfortable with the concept of the project, what it is to produce, and who its end users are.

This step also includes things like site visits and meetings with the project team, if required. Project documents like plans, drawings, specifications, and reports are obtained and the value engineering team becomes familiar with them.

2. Function Analysis

This step represents the meat and potatoes (core) of the value analysis. The team attempts to determine the functions the project serves. Functions come in two forms:

- Primary functions are those that represent the reason for the project’s existence, for example, a building project might have adequate plumbing as a primary function.

- Secondary functions are those that the project serves without being core to the project. For example, a building project might have as a secondary function maintaining the view of the neighboring building.

The functions are described in verb/noun pairs, such as “supply water to all suites,” or “Maintain view of adjacent park.” For a project like this, the team should come up with 10 – 15 functions. You might be surprised how many secondary functions exist for most projects. Subject matter experts would be a great resource, but in their absence an appropriate level of brainstorming and analysis are necessary.

The team should also identify value-mismatched functions to focus the improvements on. For ex-ample, maybe a large obstruction is preventing the view of the adjacent park from too many suites resulting in a potential mismatch of the cost vs. functional benefit. This is investigated in the next step.

3. Creative

This phase represents the generation of improvement ideas. The team develops alternative ways that the project can perform the functions that have been identified. At this step, the functions are looked at individually and each one gets a list of alternative ways to perform the function. There is no judging between the importance of the various functions.

4. Evaluation

At this stage, a priority is given to each project improvement idea. The ideas are discussed and potential costs are determined. Once the risk-reward profile of each idea is itemized, the team has determined which ideas are worth implementing into the project or feature.

A few years ago, there was a pedestrian bridge built near my home which was originally designed for emergency vehicles. Although this type of design is standard practice for the bridges of this type, the value engineering team identified that emergency vehicle passage was not needed (verb/noun pair = ‘maintain passage for emergency vehicles‘). Also, a second major outcome of this value analysis was to change the design to an aesthetic, curved bridge because it was in a prominent location. The redesign of the bridge cost some money but this was more than made up by the cost of the bridge construction. Thus, the value analysis paid for itself about 10 times over in the reduced construction cost, and the bridge was significantly more aesthetic.

5. Development

Once the value improvement options have been whittled down to the ones that make sense, the value engineering team develop the options to the point of passing them back to the original project team. They must be clearly written and explained so that the project owner and stakeholders can understand how it benefits the project and act on it. Any potential negative factors are identified. Potential costs and cost savings are itemized.

6. Presentation

This last phase represents the presentation of the alternatives to the stakeholders. Often value engineering represents a change in the normal practices that people are used to, an “out of the box thinking.” Thus the best salesperson on the team is often the best one to do the presentation.

Some typical products of a value engineering analysis are a briefing document, risk analy-sis, present worth analysis, advantages vs. disadvantages, etc.

Explanation

The specification that is produced too detailed will incur unnecessary cost because it does not allow suppliers to use their expertise in finding the most efficient way to produce it.

'No, because higher requirements in specification, the greater bargaining power of buying organi-sation': more detailed specifications could tighten the supplier base and potentially leave buying organisation with fewer potential supplier. This may reduce buyer's bargaining power in negotia-tion.

'Yes, because higher requirements will help buying organisation find the best supplier': in some circumstances, higher requirements will lead to smaller supplier base. In the worst scenario, there is no supplier who has capability to carry out those requirements

'Yes, because optimising the specification is the only method to achieve value for money': There are other methods to achieve cost saving and value for money, inter alia, volume concentration, relationship restructuring, etc.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (paraphrased from CIPS L4M2 content)

CIPS L4M2 explains that specifications in procurement serve several fundamental purposes, including:

Defining the requirement clearly – so that all stakeholders (user, buyer, supplier) have a shared understanding of what is needed.

Forming the technical basis for contracts and orders – what is being purchased.

Providing measurable criteria to assess quality and conformance – what will be inspected and tested.

Therefore:

A. To define the requirements – correct. This is one of the primary roles of a specification.

D. To provide a means of evaluating the quality or conformance – correct. Specifications set the criteria against which delivered goods/services are checked.

The other options do not reflect the core role of specifications:

B. Supplier appraisal and selection – this uses specifications indirectly but supplier appraisal is a separate process (using financial, capability, and performance criteria).

C. Define the bargaining strength of the buyer – bargaining strength is shaped by market structure and spend, not by the specification itself.

E. Minimise the bargaining strength of the supplier – not an explicit purpose of specification, and could actually backfire (e.g. over-specification reducing competition).

Relevant CIPS L4M2 areas:

Purpose and role of specifications in the procurement cycle

Specification as a basis for quality assurance and contract management

Links between specification and supplier evaluation

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (paraphrased from CIPS L4M2 content)

CIPS L4M2 warns against over-specification – defining requirements in more detail, higher quality, or tighter tolerances than are actually needed. Key consequences include:

Increased costs – suppliers incur higher production and quality costs, which are passed on to the buyer.

Fewer potential suppliers – only a small number can meet the demanding specification.

More complex supplier relationships – closer collaboration and management may be needed to meet the demanding spec.

Assessing each statement:

Ineffective SLA – if the specification is unnecessarily detailed or unrealistic, SLAs can become difficult to meet, overly complex, or focused on the wrong priorities. Likely outcome.

Higher supplier costs – very clearly a result of over-specification (tight tolerances, special materials, complex processes).

Increased SRM – when the requirement is demanding and fewer suppliers can comply, buyers often need more intensive SRM to manage performance and risk.

Reduced inventory costs – this is not a typical outcome of over-specification; if anything, higher unit costs and longer lead times can increase inventory risks and carrying costs.

Thus 1, 2 and 3 are in line with CIPS treatment of over-specification; 4 is not, so:

Correct option: C (1, 2 and 3 only)

Relevant CIPS L4M2 areas:

Dangers of over-specification (cost, risk, supplier base)

Service Level Agreements and realistic performance measures

The role of SRM in managing complex or high-dependency suppliers

Explanation

Printing and office supplies are often considered as low risk, low value items. Consolidation low value, low risk items into a broader range will dramatically increases the value of the contract and leverage of buying organisation in the negotiation.

Detailed Explanation:

A strong business case includes a clear assessment of costs, the expected benefits, and the viable options available. These criteria ensure a structured approach to decision-making and alignment with strategic goals. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Business Case Development.

Explanation

Marketing plays a critical role in sales. The marketing department introduces products to the con-sumer, and creates strategic messaging that elevates appeal and ultimately drives sales. The feed-back and response from consumers is measured by the marketing team on a variety of levels. Ad-vertising is one means of seeing what performs and what does not perform. Marketers will note trends and demand in their specific markets. This plays into new product development, because the marketing team can work with product developers to create products based on that demand.

In development of specification, the role of marketing is largely the same. They provide the market insight so that right specification is developed and it matches the demands from customers.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2 – Specification and Value Management)

CIPS L4M2 defines value engineering (VE) as a structured process used to examine functions of a product or service to ensure that each function delivers maximum value for minimum cost.

In this case, analysing functions, costs, and value-add is a textbook example of the value engineering process — used to improve or redesign specifications for future purchases.

Value analysis is retrospective, focusing on cost reduction in existing products.

Value engineering looks forward, improving design/specifications.

Since the goal is to benefit future purchasing, this is VE.

Relevant L4M2 references:

“Applying value analysis and value engineering”

“Optimising performance and cost through specification review”

Explanation

To improve production process and reduce supply risk, Datong should collaborate with suppliers early in procurement cycle. Collaborating with suppliers in this way is often referred as Early Supplier Involvement (ESI)

'Request for quotation from potential suppliers': Quotations should only be requested if the buyer know exactly what they need. In this scenario, Datong is not yet sure about the specifications of product's components, request for quotation is not a good idea.

'Mapping out business plan': A business plan, as defined by Entrepreneur, is a “written document describing the nature of the business, the sales and marketing strategy, and the financial back-ground, and containing a projected profit and loss statement.” A business plan is not appropriate with improving production process and reducing supply risk.

'Budget controlling': Budget controlling largely concerns with dealing with budget variances. Tighter budget alone cannot lead to improved processes and fewer risks.

LO 3, AC 3.1

Detailed Explanation:

Quantity discounts: Changes in order quantities can lead to cost savings, impacting budget forecasts.

Substitute goods: Using alternative products can alter planned expenses, causing budget deviations.Loan repayments and taxes are fixed financial obligations and do not directly impact procurement budgeting. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Cost Management.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2 – Market Structure and Barriers to Entry)

De-regulation removes government controls and barriers, allowing new competitors to enter, thereby increasing supplier numbers and competition.

The other options raise barriers to entry (more costs or requirements), thus reducing potential entrants.

Relevant L4M2 references:

“Barriers to market entry and exit”

“Impact of deregulation on supply market dynamics”

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2 – Market Power and Negotiation Leverage)

Buyer power increases when the buyer has more supply alternatives and can switch easily.

A high number of suppliers fosters competition, giving the buyer stronger leverage.

Options B–D limit choice and increase supplier power.

Relevant L4M2 references:

“Factors increasing buyer power”

“Supplier competition and negotiation advantage”

Explanation

Value analysis is often defined as a systematic process for improving the value of a product, service or project. It is typically used in the following ways:

- To determine the value of each component used

- To find cost reduction opportunities by optimising the components used

Segment analysis helps procurement and supply to shape and manage the supply markets.

There is no concept known as Variety reduction.

Standardisation is the process which is used to reduce varieties of products or parts.

In this scenario, the company's objective is cost reduction, then value analysis or value engineering is more likely to be applied. Also the company aims at reducing variety, standardisation can be combined with value analysis to produce the best results.

LO 3, AC 3.4

Explanation

Labour variance refers to a situation in which actual costs of labor differ from projected or budgeted labor costs. This concept is most commonly applied in manufacturing environments.

Labour variance either results from efficiency or rate discrepancies. Efficiency variance results when actual time worked is more or less than budgeted time for a project. Rate variance means you paid more per hour worked than expected. This may occur with overtime pay or when you have higher paid employees on a project than projected. Labour variance is fairly typical, but modest variance is usually not a big factor in manufacturing, because materials and other production costs are often much higher.

LO 1, AC 1.4

Explanation

Functional benchmarking is a comparison to similar or identical practices (e.g., the picking process for assembling customer orders, maintaining inventory controls of spare computer parts, logistics to move operational forces, etc.) within the same or similar functions outside the immediate industry. Functional benchmarking might identify practices that are superior in your functional areas in whatever industry they may exist. Functional benchmarking would be accomplished at the federal level by comparing the IRS collections process against those of American Express. Comparing copper mining techniques to coal mining techniques is an example in the private sector.

Benefits

- Provides industry trend information

- Quantitative comparisons

- Better improvement rate

Challenges

- Diverse corporate cultures

- Great need for specificity

- Not invented here. syndrome

- Common functions can be difficult to find

- Takes more time than internal or percent

- Must be able to visualize how to adapt the best practices

Source: USN Benchmarking Handbook

LO 1, AC 1.3

Detailed Explanation:

Conformance specifications outline specific technical standards or requirements that a product must meet. These ensure uniformity and compliance but do not allow flexibility for suppliers to innovate. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Specification Standards.

Explanation

A technical specification details the standards that a product or service must meet. Drawings (often called engineering drawings or technical drawings) are complementary to technical specifications

Explanation

Main risks involved in an under-specified requirement

• The product or service is not fit for use since it does not match the actual needs

• Higher cost due to corrections or reworks (proposal evaluations, scope or work monitoring, change in insulation materials or systems, reduced productivity, etc.).

• Higher operating cost on many fronts: process control, energy consumption, maintenance, etc.

• Other problems like corrosion under insulation, mold development, safety-related concerns, etc.

LO 3, AC 3.3

Detailed Explanation:

The bargaining strength of suppliers and buyers is a key factor influencing market competitiveness, as outlined in frameworks like Porter’s Five Forces. These forces dictate pricing, supply availability, and value delivery. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Market Analysis and Competitive Forces.

Explanation

Risks like natural disasters - fire, flood, or weather-related event, and cyber-attacks can disrupt the supply chain seriously. Threats and disruptions mean a loss of revenue and higher costs, which leads to a drop in profitability. And businesses can't rely on insurance alone because it doesn't cover all the costs and the customers who move to the competition. Risks must be identified early and supplier should have a plan that ensures continuous operations during disasters.

There are several steps many companies must follow to develop a solid business continuity plan. They include:

- Business Impact Analysis: Here, the business will identify functions and related resources that are time-sensitive. (More on this below.)

- Recovery: In this portion, the business must identify and implement steps to recover critical business functions.

- Organization: A continuity team must be created. This team will devise a plan to manage the disruption.

- Training: The continuity team must be trained and tested. Members of the team should also complete exercises that go over the plan and strategies.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2 – Sustainable Specification Writing)

Environmental criteria address resource use, pollution, waste, and emissions.

For machinery, specifying maximum emission limits or energy efficiency ratings ensures sustainability compliance.

Brand, location, or supplier nationality are not environmental factors.

Relevant L4M2 references:

“Environmental sustainability criteria in technical specifications”

“Life cycle environmental performance”

Detailed Explanation:

Cotton fabric is a direct cost because it is directly attributable to the production of the garments. Costs like rent, utilities, and payroll are indirect costs associated with running the business. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Cost Categorization in Procurement.

Detailed Explanation:

Conformance specifications are appropriate when the buyer has precise requirements that must be met. This ensures the final product aligns perfectly with the company’s needs, even if it limits supplier flexibility. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Conformance Specification in Procurement.

Detailed Explanation:

Acceptance testing verifies that the supplied product meets the buyer’s specification before it is formally accepted. This type of testing typically occurs during delivery or installation phases. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Quality Assurance in Procurement.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2 – Specification Types)

Outcome (or output) specifications define what outcome must be achieved, leaving suppliers freedom to decide how.

They are appropriate when multiple solutions can deliver the same performance.

Option C directly reflects this.

Options A, B, and D contradict the flexibility principle.

Relevant L4M2 references:

“Performance and outcome-based specifications”

“Encouraging innovation through output requirements”

Explanation

According to Andrew Graves, “Through-life Management involves the life-cycle management of the products, services and activities required to deliver a fully integrated capability to the customer, while reducing the cost of ownership for the customer.”

Benefits of through-life asset management can be:

- Lower total life-cycle costs

- Better match between the asset and end-user's needs

- Better supplier capabilities over time because it gains experience of buying organisation's needs.

Detailed Explanation:

1 (Reduces design need): Performance specifications focus on outcomes rather than detailed designs, saving buyer resources.

2 (Wider supply base): Allowing suppliers to propose their own solutions can attract a broader range of suppliers.Options 3 and 4 align with conformance specifications, not performance-based ones. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Specification Writing.

Explanation

In the scenario, the products have low value and high risk of supply. This group is known as bottleneck or critical in Kraljic's portfolio matrix. The objective for such items would be securing the supply. The company can achieve this goal by 'making' the products themselves, or finding an alternative option.

Diagram Description automatically generated

Explanation

In this question, you should understand the concept of cash flow and formula of cash flow. Cash flow calculates the physical money moving in and out a company's bank balance. The cash flow from sale activity is:

cash flow from sale = account receivable at beginning of the year + revenue - account receivable at the end of the year = $450,000 + $5,000,000 - $525,000 = $4,925,000

75% of direct costs was bought by credit, therefore, the company spent 25% on direct cost: -$2,500,000*25/100 = -$625,000

25% of indirect costs was bought on credit. Cash flow out on indirect costs is: -$3,000,000*75/100 = -$2,250,000

Company spent $1,500,000 on new assets funded by a loan of $1,000,000. Cash flow out from this activity is -$500,000

Company received $150,000 from selling old assets

Dividends have not been paid for another 2 months, thus, they are not accounted as cash flow out.

The bank balance at the end of the year is: $175,000 + $4,925,000 - $625,000 - $2,250,000 - $500,000 + $150,000 = $1,875,000

LO 1, AC 1.4

Explanation

The buying organisation is keen to encourage innovation so they should use the outcome or output based specification. In an outcome-based specification, umbrella statements like 'good quality', 'ambient temperature', 'convenient way' are often used. This may confuse the suppliers, and it's hard to check the solution that supplier offers. On the other hand, ouput-based specifications often include measurable requirements. For example, a specification for air conditioning system states that the system should maintain the room temperature at 19-24 degrees Celsius. Therefore, output specification is more appropriate in this case.

Detailed Explanation:

Conformance specifications are highly detailed, covering exact materials, dimensions, tolerances, and technical drawings. They ensure precision in manufacturing and consistency between suppliers. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Specification and Contract Development.

Detailed Explanation:

Zero-based budgeting emphasizes starting from scratch and justifying all expenses.

3 (Budget flexibility): Ensures resources are allocated dynamically based on needs.

4 (Focus on operational issues): Encourages alignment with operational priorities rather than historical trends.Using prior figures (1) is contrary to zero-based budgeting principles. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Financial Planning and Budgeting.

Explanation

Internal stakeholders may contribute to defining needs and drafting the specification by using their technical expertise. In this scenario, IT team may consult procurement team on the technical specification of the software, including compatibility with company's current IT system.

Explanation

Break even point = Fixed costs/(Price-variable cost). In this case, break even point = 20,000/(100-60) = 500

Explanation

With strategic suppliers, the aim should be to work co-operatively with them to find ways of reducing costs to achieve a target cost. It is necessary to work with the suppliers in carrying out open book costing by having first persuaded them of the need to do it. Open book can be used to establish a Target Cost, a Compensation Event value and can eventually be used to ensure the payment of actual costs to an organization. A number of forms of contract cater for this functionality of which only the NEC goes to into any great depth of methodology.

If the suppliers worry about leak of confidential information, procurement team can suggest them to sign a non-disclosure agreement. The buying organisation should also comply with data protection regulations. The Employer / individual responsible for a project’s costs should ultimately take a pragmatic and sensible approach with regard to commercially or personally sensitive data provided by the contractor. The primary goal of all open book cost management is to provide Employer comfort and security in the accuracy of commercial data; this effectively means striking a balance between undertaking full audits and blind faith.

Explanation

One product substitutes for another if it offers buyers an inducement to switch that exceeds the cost or overcomes the resistance to doing so. A substitute offers an inducement to switch if the substitute provides the buyer with more value relative to its price than the product currently being used. There is always some cost of switching to a substitute because of the disruption and potential reconfiguration of buyer activities that must result, however. The threat of a substitute will vary depending on the size of the inducement relative to the required switching costs.

In addition to relative value to price and switching cost, the pattern of substitution is influenced by what I term the buyer’s propensity to switch. Faced with equivalent economic inducements for substitution, different buyers will often evaluate substitution differently. The threat of substitution, then, is a function of three factors:

• The relative value/ price of a substitute compared to an industry’s product

• The cost of switching to the substitute

• The buyer’s propensity to switch

Porter, Michael E.. Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance (p. 278). Free Press. Kindle Edition.

The price-to-book ratio compares a company's market value to its book value. The market value of a company is its share price multiplied by the number of outstanding shares. The book value is the net assets of a company.

The price-to-earnings ratio (P/E ratio) is the ratio for valuing a company that measures its current share price relative to its earnings per share (EPS). The price-to-earnings ratio is also sometimes known as the price multiple or the earnings multiple.

The reserve ratio is the portion of reservable liabilities that commercial banks must hold onto, rather than lend out or invest. This is a requirement determined by the country's central bank, which in the United States is the Federal Reserve. It is also known as the cash reserve ratio.

LO 2, AC 2.2

Detailed Explanation:

Project A's shorter payback period means the initial investment is recovered more quickly, which is often preferred in cost models. The higher initial cost is offset by substantial cash flows, making it the more viable option based on ROI. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Investment Appraisal Techniques.

Detailed Explanation:

Given that the provision for 'risk for additional resource' exists and this is the first occurrence, James should reject the price increase as the supplier should account for these risks in their pricing. Reference: CIPS Level 4, Contract Management and Cost Control.

Explanation

Using Porter's value chain helps procurement professionals know what are direct and indirect costs of supplier. Information on direct and indirect costs will have been collected as part of the market analysis. Information sources that may help include the following:

- Company annual reports

- Market data

- Technical data

- Request for information

- Plan visits

- Discount lists

Market data is the information that is collected and analysed by specialist organisations like Mintel, Gartner, Forrester,...

Explanation

Through-life Management involves the life-cycle management of the products, services and activities required to deliver a fully integrated capability to the customer, while reducing the cost of ownership for the customer.

Diagram, table Description automatically generated

Source: Andrew Graves

The installation stage occurs in In-Service Operations. At this stage, the machinery is shipped and installed on the buyer's premises and check to ensure that it is working to the standards set out in the design specification.

Explanation

The buyer won't pay the supplier until next month. This is a liability to the buyer. This amount can be recorded as accrued expense or accounts payable. On the other hand, the supplier has not sent the invoice, so it should be accrued expense.

Both accounts payables and accrued expenses are liabilities. Accounts payable is the total amount of short-term obligations or debt a company has to pay to its creditors for goods or services bought on credit. With accounts payables, the vendor's or supplier's invoices have been received and recorded.

On the other hand, accrued expenses are the total liability that is payable for goods and services that have been consumed by the company or received. However, accrued expenses are those bills in which an invoice or bill has not yet been received. As a result, accrued expenses can sometimes be an estimated amount of what's owed, which is adjusted later to the exact amount, once the invoice has been received.

Conversely, accounts payable should represent the exact amount of the total owed from all of the invoices received.

Explanation

Based on variability, the costs has been classified into three categories, they are fixed, variable and semi variable. Fixed costs, as its name suggests, is fixed in total i.e. irrespective of the number of output produced. Variable costs vary with the number of output produced. Semi-variable is the type of costs, which have the characteristics of both fixed costs and variable costs (Source: Key Differences).

Among above costs, leasing and depreciation are relatively static and do not change if volume of business activities increase or reduce.

Packaging, utilities and annual business rate (tax) are variable costs.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (paraphrased from CIPS L4M2 content)

In CIPS L4M2, a business case is defined as the document or analysis that:

Sets out the need or problem,

Identifies and compares options (including “do nothing”),

Assesses the costs, benefits, risks and impacts of each option,

Provides a clear recommendation supported by evidence.

Its primary purpose is to provide decision-makers with a justification for investment or change, based on a structured evaluation.

Thus:

Option A – correctly describes the main purpose: assessing costs and benefits of options.

Options B, C and D – these are decisions or outputs that might be informed by a business case, but they are not what a business case “allows” by definition.

Approving sourcing strategies or supplier lists is normally part of procurement governance, influenced by the business case but not the same as it.

Approving final spend is a financial approval decision that follows from the business case evaluation.

Relevant CIPS L4M2 areas:

Structure and purpose of a business case

Option appraisal, costs, benefits and risk analysis

The role of the business case in justifying external sourcing

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (paraphrased from CIPS L4M2 content)

CIPS L4M2 explains that general inflation indices (like consumer or retail price indices) are based on a basket of goods and services for the whole economy, not tailored to a specific company’s imports or input mix.

For an engineering business importing from the USA, its price changes will depend on:

Specific industrial input price indices (e.g. metals, components, specialist goods),

Exchange rate movements GBP/USD,

Sector-specific factors (technology, capacity, freight, tariffs).

Therefore, simply “adding a published inflation index” to last year’s prices cannot precisely predict next year’s prices, particularly when:

The index may include irrelevant items like food, clothing, local services, etc.

It may not reflect the specific mix of industrial inputs or the effects of exchange rates.

Thus:

Option A correctly explains the limitation: the inflation index may include products and services that are not relevant to the company’s purchases.

Option B mentions price adjustment formulas (which can be more precise if designed well), but the question emphasises whether using a general index alone is precise – option A goes straight to the core reason.

Options C and D describe partial truths (indices can show general trends and give a quick check) but they do not support precise forecasting.

Relevant CIPS L4M2 areas:

Use and limitations of inflation indices in cost forecasting

Factors influencing prices in international procurement (currency, indices, market conditions)

Building realistic cost assumptions in a business case

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2 – Sustainable Procurement Evaluation)

Environmental criteria: carbon emissions, waste, resource efficiency.

Social criteria: labour standards, equality, community impact.

Thus, 1 and 2 fit perfectly.

Items 3 and 4 are quality or service considerations, not sustainability metrics.

Relevant L4M2 references:

“Incorporating sustainability in tender evaluation”

“Triple bottom line and responsible sourcing”

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2 – Market Entry Barriers)

Aerospace manufacturing demands high capital investment (robotics, technology, safety).

This creates a strong barrier to entry, limiting new competitors.

Industries like hospitality or insurance require far less fixed investment.

Relevant L4M2 references:

“Capital intensity and technological barriers in markets”

“Examples of entry barriers in industrial sectors”

Explanation

Overhead variances arise when the actual overhead costs incurred differ from the expected amounts. Managers want to understand the reasons for these differences, and so should consider computing one or more of the overhead variances described below. Each of these variances applies to a different aspect of overhead expenditures. It is not necessary to calculate these variances when a manager cannot influence their outcome.

Fixed Overhead Spending Variance

The fixed overhead spending variance is the difference between the actual fixed overhead expense incurred and the budgeted fixed overhead expense. An unfavorable variance means that actual fixed overhead expenses were greater than anticipated. The formula for this variance is:

Actual fixed overhead - Budgeted fixed overhead = Fixed overhead spending variance

The amount of expense related to fixed overhead should (as the name implies) be relatively fixed, and so the fixed overhead spending variance should not theoretically vary much from the budget.

Fixed Overhead Volume Variance

The fixed overhead volume variance is the difference between the amount of fixed overhead actually applied to produced goods based on production volume, and the amount that was budgeted to be applied to produced goods. For example, a company budgets for the allocation of $25,000 of fixed overhead costs to produced goods at the rate of $50 per unit produced, with the expectation that 500 units will be produced. However, the actual number of units produced is 600, so a total of $30,000 of fixed overhead costs are allocated. This creates a fixed overhead volume variance of $5,000.

Variable Overhead Efficiency Variance

The variable overhead efficiency variance is the difference between the actual and budgeted hours worked, which are then applied to the standard variable overhead rate per hour. The formula is:

Standard overhead rate x (Actual hours - Standard hours)

= Variable overhead efficiency variance

A favorable variance means that the actual hours worked were less than the budgeted hours, resulting in the application of the standard overhead rate across fewer hours, resulting in less expense being incurred. However, a favorable variance does not necessarily mean that a company has incurred less actual overhead, it simply means that there was an improvement in the allocation base what was used to apply overhead.

Variable Overhead Spending Variance

The variable overhead spending variance is the difference between the actual and budgeted rates of spending on variable overhead. The variance is used to focus attention on those overhead costs that vary from expectations. The formula is:

Actual hours worked x (Actual overhead rate - standard overhead rate)

= Variable overhead spending variance

A favorable variance means that the actual variable overhead expenses incurred per labor hour were less than expected.

In the study guide, CIPS splits overhead variance into volume and expenditure variance. They can be understood as variable and fixed overhead variance respectively.

Explanation

This International Standard (ISO 27001:2013) has been prepared to provide requirements for establishing, implementing, maintaining and continually improving an information security management system. The adoption of an information security management system is a strategic decision for an organization. The establishment and implementation of an organization’s information security management system is influenced by the organization’s needs and objectives, security requirements, the organizational processes used and the size and structure of the organization. All of these influencing factors are expected to change over time.

The information security management system preserves the confidentiality, integrity and availability of information by applying a risk management process and gives confidence to interested parties that risks are adequately managed.

It is important that the information security management system is part of and integrated with the organization’s processes and overall management structure and that information security is considered in the design of processes, information systems, and controls. It is expected that an information security management system implementation will be scaled in accordance with the needs of the organization.

This International Standard can be used by internal and external parties to assess the organization's ability to meet the organization’s own information security requirements.

The order in which requirements are presented in this International Standard does not reflect their importance or imply the order in which they are to be implemented. The list items are enumerated for reference purpose only.

ISO/IEC 27000 describes the overview and the vocabulary of information security management systems, referencing the information security management system family of standards (includ-ing ISO/IEC 27003[2], ISO/IEC 27004[3] and ISO/IEC 27005[4]), with related terms and defini-tions.

Explanation

Cracks on the jet engine is a closed-end problem. A typical problem solving process has 8 steps:

Step 1: Define the Problem

- What is the problem?

- How did you discover the problem?

- When did the problem start and how long has this problem been going on?

- Is there enough data available to contain the problem and prevent it from getting passed to the next process step? If yes, contain the problem.

Step 2: Clarify the Problem

- What data is available or needed to help clarify, or fully understand the problem?

- Is it a top priority to resolve the problem at this point in time?

- Are additional resources required to clarify the problem? If yes, elevate the problem to your leader to help locate the right resources and form a team.

- Consider a Lean Event (Do-it, Burst, RPI, Project).

- Ensure the problem is contained and does not get passed to the next process step.

Step 3: Define the Goals

- What is your end goal or desired future state?

- What will you accomplish if you fix this problem?

- What is the desired timeline for solving this problem?

Step 4: Identify Root Cause of the Problem

- Identify possible causes of the problem.

- Prioritize possible root causes of the problem.

- What information or data is there to validate the root cause?

Step 5: Develop Action Plan

- Generate a list of actions required to address the root cause and prevent problem from getting to others.

- Assign an owner and timeline to each action.

- Status actions to ensure completion.

Step 6: Execute Action Plan

- Implement action plan to address the root cause.

- Verify actions are completed.

Step 7: Evaluate the Results

- Monitor and Collect Data.

- Did you meet your goals defined in step 3? If not, repeate th 8-Step Process.

- Were there any unforeseen consequences?

- If problem is resolved, remove activities that were added previously to contain the problem.

Step 8: Continuously Improve

- Look for additional opportunities to implement solution.

- Ensure problem will not come back and communicate lessons learned.

- If needed, repeat the 8-Step Problem Solving Process to drive further improvements.

ANA has already known what is going on, the next step they should adopt is collecting more infor-mation on the problem. If the airline is hurry to the solution, it may choose 'Generate options ad-dressing the issue'. The crack on turbine blade can be welded, or the airline replaces a new blade. However, jumping to solution without knowing the root cause does not completely solve the prob-lem. The root cause is unaddressed, then it may occur in the future. Therefore, the airline should still collect information to find the root cause, then remove it.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2 – Market Analysis)

Supplier power is low when:

Buyers can easily substitute products (Option B).

Switching costs are low, so buyers can change suppliers without difficulty (Option D).

Low competition (A) or low innovation (E) strengthens supplier power, not weakens it. High quality (C) increases supplier leverage.

Relevant L4M2 references:

“Factors influencing supplier bargaining power”

“Porter’s Five Forces model – supplier power and substitution”

Explanation

If an organisation doesn't have capability to produce a technical specification, they can draft one based on standards or consulting the suppliers.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2 – Market and Supplier Power)

Supplier power decreases when:

Many substitutes exist (buyers can switch easily).

Low switching costs allow buyers to change suppliers without penalty.

Options A, C, and E describe conditions that increase supplier power or are irrelevant to it.

Hence, B and D are correct.

Relevant L4M2 references:

“Supplier power within Porter’s Five Forces”

“Factors reducing supplier influence: substitution and switching costs”

Explanation

A firm also has to look at a myriad of other factors before setting its prices. Those factors include the offering’s costs, the demand, the customers whose needs it is designed to meet, the external environment—such as the competition, the economy, and government regulations—and other aspects of the marketing mix, such as the nature of the offering, the current stage of its product life cycle, and its promotion and distribution. If a company plans to sell its products or services in international markets, research on the factors for each market must be analyzed before setting prices. Organizations must understand buyers, competitors, the economic conditions, and political regulations in other markets before they can compete successfully.

[...]

The costs of the product—its inputs—including the amount spent on product development, testing, and packaging required have to be taken into account when a pricing decision is made. So do the costs related to promotion and distribution. For example, when a new offering is launched, its promotion costs can be very high because people need to be made aware that it exists. Thus, the offering’s stage in the product life cycle can affect its price.

Explanation

ISO 9001:2015 specifies requirements for a quality management system.

ISO 14001:2015 specifies the requirements for an environmental management system that an or-ganization can use to enhance its environmental performance. ISO 14001:2015 is intended for use by an organization seeking to manage its environmental responsibilities in a systematic manner that contributes to the environmental pillar of sustainability.

ISO 22000:2018 specifies food safety management systems — Requirements for any organization in the food chain

ISO 27001 provides requirements for an information security management system.

LO 3, AC 3.1

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2 – Specification Control)

A conformance specification defines exact technical details (dimensions, materials, design).

It ensures identical compatibility with existing items.

Hence, Option A is correct.

Performance or outcome specifications would allow variations, which are not acceptable here.

Relevant L4M2 references:

“Conformance vs performance specifications”

“Specification alignment for compatibility”

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2: Market Analysis)

Competitiveness is determined by market structure—how many suppliers operate and how concentrated they are.

A large number of suppliers = competitive market; few suppliers = oligopoly/monopoly → less competitive.

Hence, C is correct.

Relevant CIPS L4M2 Sections:

Market competitiveness and supplier concentration

Market intelligence for sourcing strategies

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation (from CIPS L4M2: Market Management)

Primary data = data collected first-hand by the buyer for a specific purpose.

Secondary data = data collected by others and reused (e.g. reports, indices).

A. Price lists collected directly from suppliers at trade fairs represent first-hand market data.

B, C, D are all secondary – they originate from external publications and existing datasets.

Hence, A is correct.

Relevant CIPS L4M2 Sections:

Sources of data for supply market analysis

Differences between primary and secondary data

Explanation

There are four common types of budgets that companies use: (1) incremental, (2) activity-based, (3) value proposition, and (4) zero-based.

Incremental budgeting takes last year’s actual figures and adds or subtracts a percentage to obtain the current year’s budget. It is the most common method of budgeting because it is simple and easy to understand.

Activity-based budgeting is a top-down budgeting approach that determines the amount of inputs required to support the targets or outputs set by the company. For example, a company sets an out-put target of $100 million in revenues. The company will need to first determine the activities that need to be undertaken to meet the sales target, and then find out the costs of carrying out these ac-tivities.

In value proposition budgeting, the budgeter considers the following questions:

- Why is this amount included in the budget?

- Does the item create value for customers, staff, or other stakeholders?

- Does the value of the item outweigh its cost? If not, then is there another reason why the cost is justified?

Value proposition budgeting is really a mindset about making sure that everything that is included in the budget delivers value for the business. Value proposition budgeting aims to avoid unneces-sary expenditures – although it is not as precisely aimed at that goal as our final budgeting option, zero-based budgeting.

As one of the most commonly used budgeting methods, zero-based budgeting starts with the as-sumption that all department budgets are zero and must be rebuilt from scratch. Managers must be able to justify every single expense. No expenditures are automatically “okayed”. Zero-based budgeting is very tight, aiming to avoid any and all expenditures that are not considered absolutely essential to the company’s successful (profitable) operation. This kind of bottom-up budgeting can be a highly effective way to “shake things up”. This is the method used in the scenario.