L4M4 Ethical and Responsible Sourcing Questions and Answers

Explanation

EBITDA stands for 'earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization'. This is a profitability ratio and would show how profitable a business is.

EBITDA: Definition, Calculation Formulas, History, and Criticisms (investopedia.com)

Explanation

tactical is the correct answer; items that are short-term or low value are considered tactical.

Strategic sourcing is long term and high value.

Outsourcing is moving a key business function to an external company.

Insourcing is bringing a previously outsourced part of the company back in-house.

Explanation

Intracompany trading is when two departments in the same company do trading. AND when two companies owned by the same parent company do trading.

INTRA means 'within' - so it's doing business with yourself.

Internal production is often justified when a company has the necessary competencies and capacity. This approach aligns with responsible sourcing by leveraging internal capabilities for better control over quality, cost, and compliance with ethical and environmental standards.

To maintain integrity and avoid conflicts of interest, Tracey should declare the conflict and remove herself from the tender process. Ethical sourcing practices emphasize transparency and fairness, which prevent potential biases and maintain trust within procurement processes.

Explanation

Incoterms describe the point at which an item is considered 'delivered' and explains who has the risk of what during the transport of the goods.

An Invitation to Tender (ITT) is typically used for complex, high-value procurements where the quality and specific features of the goods or services are of paramount importance. This approach ensures that ethical and responsible sourcing criteria are met, aligning with best practices in procuring specialised goods or services.

The acid test, also known as the quick ratio, measures a company's ability to cover its current liabilities with its most liquid assets, excluding inventory. It is a stringent indicator of short-term financial health. By requesting this ratio, the company can assess whether a potential supplier has sufficient liquidity to meet its obligations, which is crucial when procuring strategic items.

Explanation

security, consultancy and cleaning are services which are often tendered as they tend to be high value and complex opportunities.

Office supplies and raw materials have less variables so you could use a RFQ for these instead.

A hint for this is also the word services. Security, consultancy and cleaning are services. Raw Materials and Office Supplies are goods.

The Triple Bottom Line framework evaluates an organisation's impact on social, environmental, and economic factors. Financial and environmental performance are critical components, along with social metrics, aligning with responsible sourcing goals to promote sustainability and ethical practices.

Explanation

The correct answer is financial stability (this is done by using all of those lovely ratios in chapter 1.3) and capacity and capability (which are part of Carter's 10 Cs).

At PQQ stage you're looking purely at whether the supplier is good or bad (to put it simply). You don't give them details of your requirement yet, so they're not providing a quote / pricing structure / price schedule at this point in time. That would be at the next stage, IF they pass PQQ, when you issue the tender competition.

Explanation

Incoterms describe the point at which an item is considered 'delivered' and explains who has the risk of what during the transport of the goods.

Explanation

An ITT would include details on the awarding body (usually a brief overview of the buyer), the deadline (bids must be received by a certain date) and qualifications required (such as ISO requirements or competency certificates of staff members if it's a service contract). You wouldn't find pricing schedules in an ITT (this would be provided by the supplier in response to the ITT), nor would you find risk assessments (a supplier might be asked to provide one as part of the quality assessment of the tender though).

Invitation To Tender Simply Explained I Thornton & Lowe (thorntonandlowe.com)

Explanation

Most Economically Advantageous Tender (MEAT) is the Public Sector's go to evaluation criteria.

NOTE that this is changing from October 2023. Public Sector Procurement is currently based on legislation called PCR 2015 which itself is based on EU Procurement Directives. Now the UK has officially Brexited, we're making our own laws and the new Procurement Bill will be coming into effect in November 2024. One of the major changes is that MEAT is changing to MAT (most ad-vantageous tender - without the economical bit).

If you're sitting this exam until July 2024- you're fine- learn what the study guide says. If you're taking the exam from November 2024 I'm not sure what students are expected to do. The entire section on public sector procurement is incorrect for you. My best guess is CIPS may removequestions this section as the study guide will be wrong, but I really don't know how they plan to handle this.

The new Procurement Bill - MEAT to MAT - Hempsons - Hempsons

Explanation

A supplier who follows the CIPS Code of Conduct is more likely to meet the buyer's needs is the correct answer.

The other options are wrong:

1) Compliance with Codes of Conduct from professional bodies is optional. E.g. CIPS - no organi-sation is forced to comply with CIPS.

2) Unethical behaviour is not impossible to detect, it may be difficult but with correct due diligence and things like audits it's completely possible

3) ISO 14001 is quality management so is irelevent.

Explanation

a factory ordering a new machine is the correct answer.

Strategic sourcing is for high value, high risk items. The other options given are tactical sourcing as they are low value (eggs, paper and plastic cups).

See p.3 for the differences between tactical and strategic sourcing

Explanation

The buyer should seek a 'collaborative' relationship. Transactional and arms-length relationships are more suited to tactical sourcing. Partnerships are reserved for joint-ventures.

Intra-company trading aims to optimize internal resources by enhancing production capacity utilization and offsetting fixed costs. By supplying goods or services internally, organizations can achieve economies of scale and better allocate resources. However, compensating for less effective technology or ensuring superior internal technology over external suppliers are not primary objectives of intra-company trading.

Explanation

This is an Invitation to Tender.

The only other real document listed in Request for Quotation. This is incorrect because the document asks questions relating to how they will deliver the service. This means price isn't the only factor, which is the case for a RfQ.

Request for Tender and Invitation to Quote are not real things.

Explanation

the correct answer is 'no- the public sector can choose not to publish information if it is not deemed to be in the public interest'.

They use something called the 'public interest test' to determine if the information should be re-leased or not. For example they may not respond to a request asking how many bullets the UK Army has in storage, as that would be detrimental to national security interests.

Responses to requests are made within 21 days, not 28.

Single sourcing can be appropriate when set-up costs are high, making it impractical to involve multiple suppliers. This aligns with responsible sourcing principles, particularly for high-value or specialised items, where relationship management and collaboration with one supplier can enhance quality and efficiency.

Incoterms, short for International Commercial Terms, were introduced by the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) in 1936. These standardized terms are used globally to define the responsibilities of buyers and sellers in international trade, helping to avoid misunderstandings by clarifying tasks, costs, and risks involved in the delivery of goods.

Profitability and asset levels indicate a supplier’s financial stability and ability to meet contract demands. Responsible sourcing practices include assessing financial capacity to reduce risk in the supply chain and ensure long-term supplier viability.

Explanation

Social value is about benefitting the local community / society. Therefore of those options listed, use of local labour is the most appropriate to consider.

Employee working conditions, a code of ethics, and a carbon emissions policy are all indicative of a supplier's commitment to ESG standards. Assessing these factors aligns with responsible sourcing practices, which prioritize sustainability and ethical considerations.

Explanation

Intracompany trading is when two departments in the same company do trading. AND when two companies owned by the same parent company do trading.

INTRA means 'within' - so it's doing business with yourself.

Explanation

Weighted points systems can be time consuming to create. They're very transparent and allow for objective grading of supplier bids (so these answers are incorrect). They are not easy to manipulate and this is an advantage of using them.

Explanation

The correct answer is 'the supplier has a lot of long-term debt'. Gearing is a measure of how the business is being funded and looks at the ratio of debt to equity. For example if they have taken out lots of loans and mortgages, this would equate to a lot of debt which means a poor gearing ratio.

Gearing is a hot topic for the exam.

Providing a debrief allows suppliers to understand the tender process and learn areas of improvement, promoting transparency. This practice supports responsible sourcing by fostering a fair, competitive environment and encouraging suppliers to improve their future offerings.

Explanation

The correct answer is 'yes - these can be completed without warning which would give Ali an accurate picture of the supplier's operations'. The other options are incorrect:

1) you can do many types of audit- financial, ethical, Health and Safety etc

2) asking a supplier about their ethical practices isn't likely going to get you accurate information. They'll just tell you what they think you want to hear

3) audits are great- but they don't ALWAYS uncover issues. Always is the key word in that sentence which makes it incorrect.

Explanation

shareholder equity = the owner/s of the organisation's residual claim once all debts have been paid. What Is Shareholder Equity (SE) and How Is It Calculated? (investopedia.com)

Explanation

The best way to deal with potential Conflicts of Interest is to openly declare these. Just because you have a relationship with someone doesn't mean this is going to be an issue or lead to fraud, but it is a good idea to keep a written record of these.

It wouldn't be a risk register, because how can you rate someone's risk of doing something dodgy? Risk registers are for objective risks such as Health and Safety.

Explanation

This is sole sourcing as there is only one supplier in the marketplace.

Be careful not to confuse single sourcing and sole sourcing. Single sourcing is when a buyer chooses to work with only one supplier (usually to achieve economies of scale), sole sourcing, on the other hand, is when the buyer doesn't have a choice- they work with one supplier because there is only one supplier in the market.

Types of sourcing is a key concept for this exam.

Explanation

liquid = the ability to pay short and medium term debts. In simple terms do you have more in stuff (money, assets) than you owe in debt?

Understanding Liquidity and How to Measure It (investopedia.com)

This is a hot topic for the exam. Learn everything in this section.

Explanation

a balance sheet shows 'equity, assets and liabilities'. The other financial statements you need to know for this exam are cash flow statements and and income statements.

If you're not familiar with these three I strongly recommend you do some further reading on this before the exam if you can. This is helpful: How the 3 Financial Statements are Linked Together - Step by Step (corporatefinanceinstitute.com)

Addressing human rights issues collaboratively by developing an action plan allows for improvement and correction. This approach is consistent with ethical sourcing principles, which encourage responsible intervention to correct and improve supply chain practices rather than punitive measures that may not lead to long-term change.

Phishing is categorized as fraud because it involves deceptive practices to gain sensitive information or financial benefits. Responsible sourcing includes ensuring that cybersecurity measures are in place to prevent fraud and protect sensitive information within supply chains.

A current ratio below 1 suggests that the supplier may not have sufficient current assets to cover short-term liabilities, which could pose a risk to the buyer. Assessing financial stability aligns with responsible sourcing practices, as it ensures suppliers can fulfill contracts without disruption.

Explanation

Open tenders should be used when the buyer expects there to be little interest / fewer bids. The opportunity is advertised widely allowing any supplier that wishes to submit a bid the opportunity.

The other options limit the number of suppliers and Ji Yuan doesn't want to do that, because he risks getting no interest and no supplier.

P.23

Explanation

ISO9001 is Quality Management so is therefore the correct answer. The other options can be used to appraise suppliers but do not link directly or fully to Quality Management.

Explanation

Primary data includes trade fairs and exhibits, and phone calls to current suppliers. The others are examples of secondary data.

Remember primary= you do it yourself, Secondary = someone else did it.

Explanation

ethics and environment are not a 'right of procurement'.

The 5 rights are price, quality, quantity, time and place.

Explanation

a factory ordering a new machine is the correct answer.

Strategic sourcing is for high value, high risk items. The other options given are tactical sourcing as they are low value (eggs, paper and plastic cups).

See p.3 for the differences between tactical and strategic sourcing

Explanation

Primary data includes trade fairs and exhibits, and phone calls to current suppliers. The others are examples of secondary data.

Remember primary= you do it yourself, Secondary = someone else did it.

Engaging with business managers while making sourcing recommendations ensures that the buyer considers multiple perspectives, reducing potential biases and improving decision-making. This approach aligns with ethical sourcing practices by promoting collaboration and transparency in tender decisions.

Evaluating total life-cycle costs, including initial purchase price and long-term maintenance, aligns with ethical sourcing by promoting cost-effective and sustainable procurement. It ensures value for money and supports environmentally and financially responsible sourcing practices.

Explanation

The correct answer is Invitation to Tender. This is sent out to suitable suppliers inviting them to bid for the opportunity.

A PQQ - pre-qualification questions naire- is sent to suppliers to see if they are suitable. The QUESTION NO: states these suppliers have already been deemed suitable, so they've already passed PQQ

A RFQ - request for quotation- would be used when the only variable is price, so is not suitable for complex tenders.

RFT isn't a thing. I made the last one up.

Explanation

You should investigate automatically low tenders by clarifying the bid with the supplier. It could be they have misunderstood the requirement. Or the bid could be genuine and they can really provide best value for money. But without enquiring, you just don't know.

Explanation

Incoterms can replace lengthy contract clauses as they replace the need for contracts to detail which party is responsible for organising transport, paying duties, having the insurance etc.

Incoterms is an odd one for exam topics- some students say it was a huge part of their exam and there were many questions on this. Others said there were just one or two. Questions get randomly assigned from the bank so it's completely random how many you'll get on this topic.

Explanation

A credit rating generates a score which reflects 'the level of risk an organisation poses when dealing with other businesses'. It's saying how risky it is to loan them money or do business with them by looking at how good they are at paying people. So a high credit rating will say they're good at paying back their loans and paying their suppliers on time. A poor credit rating will say they often miss payments or pay late.

A credit rating will not tell you how much money they have, or details on their prices. Credit scores looks at purely financial data so wouldn't help you analyse whether their business practices are ethical or not.

Explanation

Cleaning and Facilities Management are the most appropriate items to outsource. They would not outsource the making of confectionary products as this is the 'core' business.

See p.4 for "what is outsourcing?"

Explanation

The C category is the 'tail spend' - it represents a large number of suppliers of small value items.

I recommend giving this a read ABC Classification & ABC Method | CIPS

The gross profit margin ratio is calculated by subtracting the cost of goods sold (COGS) from income from sales, then dividing by income from sales. This ratio indicates the profitability of a supplier, a critical factor in assessing financial health, which helps buyers ensure reliable supply continuity.

Explanation

The correct answer is 'yes- because a low credit rating would indicate the supplier is financially un-stable'.

The two options beginning with no should automatically be discounted. The other option is incor-rect because credit ratings are private and would therefore not affect reputation.

Explanation

The CIPS Code of Conduct says to adhere to all laws of countries in which I practice. So if you're in the UK and procure stuff from China, you need to abide by both UK and Chinese laws, not just UK laws.

There's no international procurement laws- these are all different for different countries.

ILO doesn't publish laws.

Professional magazines, economic indices, and supplier websites provide secondary data that can be useful in understanding market trends and supplier performance. Responsible sourcing often relies on a mix of primary and secondary data sources to make informed decisions about supplier selection.

Explanation

the correct answer is 'Yes- a low gearing ratio means the company's finances are made up of equity rather than debt'.

Remember low gearing = good (based on equity), high gearing = bad (based on debt). Anything over 50% is considered high.

The two no answers are therefore incorrect and you can discount these straight away. The other yes answer is one of those answers which COULD be true, but isn't always true, and we'd need more information to know for sure. When you get options like this there will be one that is always right and one which is sometimes right - so always pick the always right one.

Dealing with supply chain disruptions is complex, and depending what the disruption is, how big it is, what the industry is etc determines whether a supplier can handle it or not. Because there's more factors to consider than just gearing, this isn't the right answer.

Explanation

Social value is about benefitting the local community / society. Therefore of those options listed, use of local labour is the most appropriate to consider.

Explanation

Raja should send out a RFI- request for information; this will allow him to gain feedback from the marketplace prior to tender.

Speaking only with current suppliers will not provide all the information Raja requires.

He should not send out a request for quotation since he is still conducting market research

An open competition would be how he can procure, after he's completed his research

Regularly checking supplier policies and conflict of interest registers helps ensure that suppliers are upholding ethical standards, which supports responsible sourcing practices. This governance activity aligns with ethical guidelines to promote transparency and prevent conflicts that could affect the integrity of the supply chain.

Multi-sourcing allows organisations to diversify their supply base, providing flexibility, and reducing risk by having multiple suppliers. It is an effective strategy to prevent over-dependence on a single source and allows for competition among suppliers, promoting quality and ethical standards in the supply chain.