L4M6 Supplier Relationships Questions and Answers

In the Norming stage of Tuckman’s model of team development, teams begin to resolve their differences, appreciate each other's strengths, and respect authority. Agreement on design and role assignment indicates the team has moved past conflict (Storming) and is now functioning collaboratively, although not yet fully productive (Performing).

Explanation

The correct answer is ‘Conduct regular audits’. This is explained on p.153. You wouldn’t do an appraisal on a supplier in a partnership relationship as both parties are equal. Threatening a partner isn’t good for the relationship and a damages clause would be used in a contractual relationship rather than a partnership.

For partnerships to succeed, both buyer and supplier must see significant value in the relationship. High spend indicates strategic importance, ensuring mutual commitment. If the buyer is a core customer for the supplier, and has a high spend, partnership sourcing is mutually beneficial.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

Differentiation involves offering unique products or services that are valued by customers, allowing the company to charge premium prices. This strategy focuses on uniqueness and added value rather than competing solely on cost.

Explanation

This is 'cost focus' - Kinky Boots is both focusing on being a cost leaser (by providing the cheapest products) and focusing on a niche market (drag queens). When these two strategies are combined it is called 'cost focus'. There's a couple of questions on Porter's Generic Strategies in the exam- there's a useful diagram of this on P.13

Explanation

The correct answers are; tradeshows, internal stakeholders’ knowledge and e-procurement platforms. Intranet is incorrect as this is an internal system so you wouldn’t find information on external suppliers on here the careful not to confuse intranet with internet). OJEU is also incorrect; this is the platform on which tender opportunities in the public sector are published- its not a list of suppliers.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

A restricted market is characterized by high barriers to entry, often due to stringent government regulations and the need for substantial financial investment. These factors limit the number of new entrants, resulting in a market dominated by a few established suppliers. While existing suppliers may offer excellent services, the key defining features of a restricted market are the regulatory constraints and the significant capital required to compete.

Setting minimum standards helps filter suppliers efficiently, ensuring that only capable and reliable suppliers are considered. This approach supports both cost and quality objectives.

Explanation

This question is very, very similar to a real exam QUESTION NO: and is a really mean one. The CIPS study guide describes stages of team development as forming, storming, norming and performing. Of those listed in the book only forming is listed above. What the textbook fails to tell you is that some people add on two additional stages to this model which are mourning and adjourning. I strongly recommend doing some further reading on this (it’s called the Tuckman Group Development Model) as it comes up a lot in the exam and the study guide doesn’t really go into enough detail.

Pareto Analysis is based on the 80/20 principle, which CIPS uses to help procurement professionals:

Identify the small number of items accounting for the majority of spend or value

Focus effort where it adds the most value

Key activities include:

Prioritising procurement time and resources (Statement 1 ✔)

Separating spend into critical few and trivial many (Statement 3 ✔)

Statement 2 relates to Kraljic portfolio analysis, and Statement 4 relates to supplier preferencing, not Pareto.

L4M6 Reference:

Learning Outcome 1: Understand procurement analysis and segmentation tools

Topic: Pareto (80/20) analysis

CIPS L4M6 Study Guide – Spend analysis and prioritisation

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

Early Supplier Involvement (ESI) refers to the practice of involving suppliers early in the product development process to leverage their expertise and capabilities. Cross-organisational involvement entails collaboration across various departments within the organization, such as procurement, engineering, manufacturing, and R&D, to ensure the product design is feasible and efficient for production.

The relationship reflects a partnership due to the strategic alignment, resource sharing, and focus on long-term growth, even without a formal contract. CIPS highlights that partnerships are based on trust and collaboration.

The relationship spectrum runs from adversarial/transactional to collaborative partnerships such as strategic alliances and co-destiny. Also included are mid-spectrum arrangements like single sourcing and arm’s length. Options 2 and 3 list valid relationship types, making 2 and 3 correct.

Explanation

The correct answer is ‘Yes-partnerships do not have end dates because they involve significant investment’. This is explained on p.126. Partnerships can involve contracts – so the other ‘yes’ answer is incorrect.

Partnerships are built on trust and transparency, with shared benefits such as cost reductions and improved processes. Adversarial relationships, in contrast, focus on price and contractual obligations.

Explanation

This is based on a real exam question- it's looking to see if you can remember Carter's 10 Cs. These are; cash, cost, consistency, culture, clean, communication, competency, capacity, commitment and control. (p.12 in the text book)

Explanation

In a 'perfect competition' there are no barriers to entry or exit, and competition is at its highest possible level. For more information on different types of market see p.40

CIPS defines value for money (VFM) as achieving the optimal balance between cost, quality, and sustainability over the whole life of the requirement.

Public sector procurement is governed by principles of:

Transparency

Fairness

Accountability

Best use of public funds

VFM does not mean lowest price; it means best outcome for the organisation and taxpayers, which includes quality, risk, and whole-life cost.

L4M6 Reference:

Learning Outcome 1: Understand objectives of procurement and supply

Topic: Public sector procurement objectives

CIPS L4M6 Study Guide – Value for money and public accountability

Bottleneck suppliers often control critical or scarce resources. Developing relationships with these suppliers is crucial to mitigate risks and ensure continuity of supply, per procurement best practices.

Confidentiality is critical in professional relationships, especially for law firms, as they handle sensitive client information. Ensuring that all legal obligations to protect this information are met aligns with ethical and legal best practices.

Obtaining multiple quotations ensures value for money by comparing suppliers based on cost, quality, and other criteria. It promotes competitive pricing and informed decision-making.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

In Michael Porter's Value Chain model, primary activities are those that are directly involved in the creation and delivery of a product or service. These include:

Inbound Logistics:Activities related to receiving, storing, and distributing inputs internally.

Operations:Transforming inputs into the final product.

Outbound Logistics:Distributing the final product to customers.

Marketing and Sales:Activities that inform buyers about products and services, induce buyers to purchase them, and facilitate their purchase.

Service:Activities that maintain and enhance the product's value, such as customer support and repair services.

Firm infrastructure and technology development are considered support activities, as they assist the primary activities in helping the organization achieve its competitive advantage.

Explanation

Barriers to entry are economies of scale (in the air travel industry you can't just start off small and grow), access to capital (you need to already have a lot of money to buy airplanes) and licences and permits (you need to ensure you have the correct licences to fly planes). These are listed on p.41. Other barriers include; strong brand identity already dominant in the market, high switching costs for buyers, access to distribution networks and government policy.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

The buying organisation's decision to terminate the partnership with supplier FGH is influenced by:

Changes in the composition of the supply market: The entry of new suppliers into the market provides the buying organisation with more options, reducing dependency on FGH and enabling the pursuit of better partnerships.

Poor communication by the supplier: FGH's lack of proactive communication regarding delivery delays has led to frustration, indicating a breakdown in the partnership's effectiveness.

These factors align with the principles of supplier relationship management, where effective communication and adaptability to market changes are crucial.

Explanation

This is a threat of a new entrant. The competitor has now entered the washing machine market and is competing directly with you. This is not a threat of substitution as it is the same product. A substitution would be if they invented a new product that washed clothes and people started buying this instead of washing machines. There are many questions in the exam on Porter's 5 Forces - see p. 39

Economic factors such as unemployment rates affect labor availability, wages, and consumer purchasing power, directly impacting business operations and supply chains.

When contracts for services transfer between providers, TUPE regulations (Transfer of Undertakings – Protection of Employment) apply in many jurisdictions. Employees retain their rights and continue employment under the new employer. Thus, employment rights are the key legal concern.

Explanation

The correct answer is Measurable, achievable and relevant. This is from SMART KPIs on p. 151. Smart stands for specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, time-bound. In the exam they come up in different orders so be careful.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

By acquiring an Australian office furniture manufacturer, COFM can:

Access the Restricted Local Market:Acquisition allows COFM to operate as a local entity, thereby overcoming barriers to entry and benefiting from any local government support available to domestic manufacturers.

Improve Knowledge of the Local Market:The acquired company brings with it an understanding of local customer preferences, regulatory requirements, and market dynamics, which is invaluable for successful operations.

However, the acquisition does not remove government support for other local manufacturers, nor does it necessarily decrease competition.

In the context of the IT equipment industry,Technologicalfactors are paramount. The rapid pace of technological advancement influences product development, supply chain processes, and market competitiveness. Utilizing the STEEPLED framework, technological considerations would significantly impact the company's supply chain strategy.

As per the CIPS Intelligence Hub:

"STEEPLED analysis is a strategic planning methodology that can be used across all business functions to discover, evaluate, organise, and track external risk."

— CIPS Intelligence Hub: Using STEEPLED analysis to develop your supply chain

Explanation

Carter's 10 Cs are a way to qualify (aka shortlist) a supplier. See p.11 for more details on this and p.10 for the stages of the relationship cycle.

Negative leaders and promoters hold the most influence. Negative leaders can sway opposition, while promoters can actively advocate for project success. Managing these stakeholders effectively is crucial in procurement projects.

Explanation

The correct answer is ‘run a restricted competition – send out a PQQ’. This QUESTION NO: tests both your understanding of when to run open and restricted competitions (which is explained on p.75) and your understanding of tender documents. Mandy should run a restricted competition- there are a lot of options in the marketplace and this will allow her to pre-qualify those who best suit her requirements. Running an open competition when there are lots of suppliers would be too time-consuming- you need a way of making a short-list. When you run a restricted competition, the first stage is sending out a PQQ- pre-qualification questionnaire; this document is sent to suppliers asking for necessary information to support their qualification as an approved supplier.

Profitability is impacted when product costs rise without corresponding price adjustments. Understanding cost-price relationships is key to managing profitability in procurement.

Explanation

Using an external supplier always comes with increased risk, as you become dependant upon them, and have less control over their performance (compared to an in-house team). In this example Harry will have the increased risk that the contract cleaners turn up late to their shifts, or don't do a good job. However, there is no reason to believe that the supplier will not perform as well as an internal team- we don't have enough information from the QUESTION NO: for this to be true. What is true is the RISK isgreater. The other answers are incorrect; the QUESTION NO: doesn't indicate whether outsourcing the cleaning will be more or less expensive for Harry. Allowing staff to focus on other areas is an advantage not a disadvantage. See p.4 for more information on 'External Suppliers'

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

In the Supplier Preferencing Model, customers are categorized based on their attractiveness and value to the supplier. A "Nuisance" customer is characterized by low profitability and high maintenance, often requiring disproportionate resources relative to the benefits they provide. Such customers may be deprioritized or even considered for discontinuation by the supplier.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

Collaborative partnering relationships are characterized by high levels of trust, mutual objectives, shared information, and long-term commitment. Among the options provided:

Co-destiny: This represents the highest level of collaboration, where both parties' futures are closely linked, and decisions are made jointly for mutual benefit.

Strategic alliance: This involves a formal agreement between organizations to pursue shared objectives while remaining independent entities.

These relationship types are positioned on the collaborative end of the relationship spectrum, emphasizing joint efforts and shared success.

Explanation

Stationary is a routine item; it is ordered often (as Barry uses different suppliers), it is a low category spend, and low risk to the business' operations (a late delivery of pens isn't going to stop the company making its biscuits). There are lots of questions on Kraljic in the exam - do revise this topic and ensure you understand each of the four quadrants of the matrix (see p.20)

Explanation

partnerships are always win: win p.7

Explanation

Tail spend items are low value, high volume. P. 132

Explanation

STEEPLE is what is used to analyse the macro-environment; the factors are; social, technological, economic, environmental, political, legislative and ethical. Details of this can be found on p.43-44. Note in the exam they won't necessarily be given in this order.

Explanation

The definition of value mapping is given on p.69 this is; ‘a process in which value is created through the elimination of waste and operational inefficiencies’. It ties into JIT / Lean.

An amicable approach is critical when alternative suppliers are limited or when ongoing collaboration is required during the termination period. Maintaining positive relations ensures smooth operations and protects reputations in the marketplace.

Explanation

STEEPLE is what is used to analyse the macro-environment; the factors are; social, technological, economic, environmental, political, legislative and ethical. Details of this can be found on p.43-44

Explanation

This is category 'A' spend in the ABC model - they represent a large value and a small number of purchases / suppliers. See p.17 for more information on the ABC Analysis

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

The described relationship includes:

Joint Product Development:Collaborative involvement in strategic projects indicates a deep partnership.

Integrated Systems:JIT delivery systems require synchronized operations, reflecting significant integration.

These elements are hallmarks of a significant integration partnership.

Internal stakeholders are individuals or groups within an organization who are directly involved in its operations and decision-making processes. The finance director plays a crucial role in budgeting and financial planning, while maintenance engineers are essential for ensuring equipment functionality and efficiency. Both are integral to the organization's internal operations, as outlined in the CIPS L4M6 study materials.

Value-added benefits are additional services offered by suppliers that enhance the buyer’s operations without significant additional cost. These typically include:

Free training (A) – improves buyer staff skills.

Customer service hotlines (C) – improves responsiveness and support.

Expert consulting services (D) – provides specialist knowledge.

Options B, E, and F are operational necessities, not “value-added extras.”

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

Partnerships between buyers and suppliers are often driven by:

High Spend:Significant expenditure justifies the investment in developing a closer relationship to achieve cost savings and efficiencies.

Critical Products:Items that are essential to the buyer's operations necessitate a reliable and collaborative supplier relationship.

Technical Complexity:Complex products benefit from joint development efforts, shared expertise, and coordinated problem-solving.

Conversely, commodities and markets with many suppliers typically lend themselves to transactional relationships rather than partnerships.

Explanation

The correct answer is “A mechanism for performance management where the buyer has the right to deduct money from payments owed for under performance”. A definition is provided on p.113 and states “If a supplier fails to meet the standard set in the service credits, the buyer has the right to deduct set amounts of money from payments owed to the supplier”

Competitive dialogue is the most appropriate method for complex, high-value procurements where requirements cannot be fully defined at the outset. This process allows dialogue with shortlisted bidders to refine specifications and negotiate solutions before awarding. CIPS states that this procedure is particularly suited for projects requiring flexibility, multiple negotiation phases, and innovative input from suppliers.

Explanation

The correct answer is ‘Yes- partnership sourcing can improve performance which will ultimately satisfy the end customer’. The important thing to note in this QUESTION NO: is the word ‘monopolistic’. This means that there are no alternative suppliers- so the ‘no’ options are wrong- there are no alternative suppliers and no opportunity to outsource. The other answer is incorrect as sales figures isn’t Andrew’s concern – it’s the complaints and quality of the product. Improving performance to satisfy end customers is therefore his main driver for considering a Partnership. See p. 127 for more information on Drivers of Partnership Sourcing. This comes up a lot in the exam

Explanation

CPV stands for Common Procurement Vocabulary. This is explained briefly on p.72 but it doesn’t really go into much detail as to what CPVs are or how they work. CPVs are a string of numbers which refer to an object that is being procured. For example the CPV for Fire Doors is 44221220. When a Tender gets advertised for Fire Doors, it will have this CPV code on, and any suppliers who provide fire doors will get a notification if they have this CPV code on their profile. It’s basically a code that links suppliers with tender opportunities.

Value for money is achieved through a balance of quality and cost, ensuring that the goods meet performance requirements while being cost-effective, as per procurement best practices.

Shortening product life cycles require close collaboration and innovation between buyer and supplier to stay competitive. Partnership sourcing provides shared development, reduced lead times, and improved responsiveness. Stable markets or falling costs do not justify partnerships; they are best suited for high-risk, fast-changing environments.

Suppliers gain power when their products have limited substitutes, are highly differentiated, or when switching costs are high. These factors reduce buyer leverage and increase supplier influence, as described in Porter’s Five Forces model.

Selection criteria focus on the supplier’s capability and experience (e.g., method statements). Award criteria are used to evaluate and compare proposals during the tender process, such as price or environmental considerations.

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

For high-value and high-risk contracts, such as facilities management services for multiple schools,competitive tenderingis the most appropriate sourcing approach. This process involves inviting multiple suppliers to submit bids, ensuring transparency, fairness, and the opportunity to assess various proposals to select the most suitable supplier. It helps in mitigating risks and achieving value for money.

Effective partnership governance requires balanced representation from both buyer and supplier. If the supplier has fewer members than the buyer, decision-making power becomes unequal, potentially undermining collaboration.

Explanation

Pablo should use a ‘cross-functional team’. CIPS love ‘cross-functional teams’ and refer to them frequently throughout the study guide. A cross-functional team is people from different departments who come together for a purpose, such as to evaluate a tender. The benefit of using a cross-functional team is that you get people with different experiences and knowledge. So in this example a Cross-Functional team could compose of people from various departments such as procurement, logistics, manufacturing and legal. P.76

Technological factors play a pivotal role in IT equipment supply chains. Advancements, obsolescence, and innovation significantly affect production, cost, and competitiveness, making it a primary focus in supply chain development.

Explanation

This would reduce inventory (holding stock). Inventory is considered a business waste because it costs money to store stuff (e.g. paying the rent on a warehouse, electricity to light it up etc). If you can reduce the need to store materials and components on site- you reduce costs. You also save time because you get deliveries when you need them- you don’t need to allow for staff unpacking things, storing them away, then going back to them later when they need them. For more information on the 7 Business Wastes see p.70. This comes up in a couple of modules, so it’s worth remembering.

Explanation

The three right answers are competing, collaborating and compromising. See the Thomas Kilmann Model on p.87. There are quite a few questions on this in the exam.

A partnership is the most appropriate type of relationship for high-value, long-term contracts involving strategic goods or services. This relationship allows both parties to work collaboratively toward common goals, share risks, and ensure continuity and quality over the long term. According to the CIPS L4M6 study materials, partnership relationships are encouraged where there is a high level of interdependence and shared objectives.

Early supplier involvement highlights supplier strengths and capabilities, enabling collaborative development. This supports innovation and optimizes the procurement process.

The primary objective of cost modelling is to dissect and comprehend the components that constitute a supplier's pricing. By understanding the supplier's pricing strategy, the buyer can identify cost drivers, negotiate more effectively, and seek opportunities for cost savings. This approach aligns with the CIPS L4M6 guidelines, emphasizing the importance of transparency and collaboration in supplier relationships.

Explanation

This is based on a real exam question- it's looking to see if you can remember Carter's 10 Cs. These are; cash, cost, consistency, culture, clean, communication, competency, capacity, commitment and control. (p.12 in the text book)

Explanation

The 5 Rights of procurement are; place, quality, quantity, time, price. (Price and Cost are not the same thing). See p.38

Explanation

The first step is to obtain business approval to terminate. If Senior Management don’t give approval, then the rest of the stages can’t happen and Sandra will be stuck with her current banana supplier. There’s a good diagram on p.109 detailing the steps to supplier termination.

Explanation

The correct answer is ‘Building better relationships with primary stakeholders’. This is a direct quote from the start of chapter 2.2: ‘building better relationships with primary stakeholders such as employees, customers, suppliers and communities could lead to increased shareholder wealth by developing a competitive advantage’. The other three options wouldn’t give you a competitive advantage; increasing prices would do the opposite, engaging in market research won’t give you a competitive advantage unless you do something with that research such as implement a change to your business, and completing formal tenders for everything would be a waste of time and resources- there’s no need to tender for low value, low risk items. See p.80

Poor communication leads to misunderstandings, unmet expectations, and conflict, undermining partnerships. CIPS stresses the importance of transparent and regular communication to ensure alignment and success.

Explanation

The correct answer is ‘Yes- mediation involves a neutral third party and gets both parties to attempt to reach a compromise’. Be careful not to confuse mediation with arbitration – arbitration is when the buyer and supplier agree to accept a third party’s decision which will solve the disagreement issues. See p.112 for more information on solving disputes

Comprehensive and Detailed Explanation:

Statement B:A strategic alliance is an agreement between two or more parties to pursue a set of agreed-upon objectives while remaining independent organizations. It is typically managed jointly by the partners to achieve mutual benefits without forming a new legal entity.Wikipedia

Statement C:In a joint venture, two or more parties create a new, separate legal entity by contributing equity, and they share in the revenues, expenses, and control of the enterprise. This new company is formed to undertake specific business activities.

Early engagement with the whole market is crucial when entering a new technical domain. It allows the company to assess the capabilities, innovations, and fit of various suppliers before locking down specifications. CIPS guidance emphasizes the value of market engagement in developing effective specifications and selecting the right partner.

Explanation

You would expect a supplier to submit full pricing information, risk assessments and method statements. However, depending on what you’re procuring, you might not need to see risk assessments or method statements. Liquidity and Gearing may be looked at during the Pre-Qualification stage, but wouldn’t form part of a RFP. See p.76